As part of work on cleaning up the bookkeeping in the region of eta Carinae, the lists below show accurate coordinates and principal identifications for stars in the scattered region on the southern side of the eta Carinae nebula, designated Collinder 228. A small portion of the area has been covered in recent CCD surveys, but the bulk of the brighter stars have names assigned from three older photoelectric datasets. In 1976 Feinstein et al first designated 98 stars; in 1980 additional data was published by Turner & Moffat (UBV) and by The' et al (Walraven). They both extended the numbering scheme independently, but unfortunately in SIMBAD and in WEBDA the stars/numbers/data have become mixed, so that data for a star in one paper has been listed for the same number (but a different star) from the other paper. (slap forehead) For this reason the additional stars are shown with complete aliases, so that the database folks can work things out. Clearly the Turner & Moffat paper will have to have an acronym assigned in order to distinguish their stars from the The' et al stars. (There are four stars in common, which I flag in the listing for the The' et al stars.) I started by making lists using screen plots of UCAC2 and comparing against the three relevant charts. Crowded stars and other special cases were dealt with individually using large-scale DSS/2MASS images from SkyView and looking up the stars in VizieR. I show complete basic aliases: UCAC2, Tycho numbers (from any of Tycho-1, ACT, TRC, or Tycho-2) if available, and GSC numbers otherwise, CPD, CD, and HD numbers. Note that the Tycho coordinates are rarely to be preferred, since some are in error by 1"-3" due to faintness, crowding, and the overlying nebulosity (sometimes no proper motions either). For the lower HD numbers I relied on the links with the CPD given in the original catalogue along with the magnitude and color. For the HDE stars I relied on both the Nesterov et al and Fabricius et al identifications, and compared with the printed HDE chart (chart 137) when a couple of discrepancies arose. I then compared these with the HD aliases given by Feinstein et al; all were identical apart from one omission on their part (star 46 = HD 305542). I matched all the stars in VizieR against the Tycho double-star catalogue, IRAS, and the GCVS v4.2. Several uncatalogued pairs are specified in the remarks, mainly to help secure the identifications. When the data seem to apply to the combined light of a pair, I show the averaged position rounded to 1" precision. All this stuff is collected in several 124-column wide tables whose columns should be self-evident. I have added the rounded V magnitude as an aid in identification. Again using VizieR I matched the lists against the Massey & Johnson survey, the recent Carraro et al paper, and the Cudworth et al astrometric survey. Surprisingly few links were found, but the aliases are shown at the bottom of the file after the main tables. (Fein = Feinstein et al, TM = Turner & Moffat, MJ = Massey & Johnson (1993AJ....105..980M), Carraro = 2001A&A...379..136C, and Cudworth = 1993AJ....105.1822C) Special case: Feinstein et al neglected to label star 42 on their chart. It was easy to identify from the chart numbering sequence and the photometry. The star was observed (as new) by both Turner & Moffat (their 116) and by The' et al (their 115). The mixed photometry in SIMBAD and WEBDA is an example also where the latter two IDs have been switched. The crowded clusters Trumpler 14 and 16 (and Collinder 232) remain to be dealt with even for the "bright" stars, and then ultimately the various CCD lists will need to be stitched together. Hic labor, hic opus est. \Brian P.S.: corrections are welcome (particularly from Fabienne or Ernst!), which will be made to this file and copied to: ftp://ftp.lowell.edu/pub/bas/ocpos/cr228.pos ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Coordinates and identifications for stars in Collinder 228 version: 16 Oct 2006 position sources (column 's'): M 2MASS (2006AJ....131.1163S, II/246) T Tycho-2 (2000A&A...357..367H, I/259) U UCAC2 (2004AJ....127.3043Z, I/289) source: 1976A&AS...24..389F FEINSTEIN A., MARRACO H.G., and FORTE J.C. Astron. Astrophys., Suppl. Ser., 24, 389-397 (1976) Collinder 228 and the eta Carinae complex. Dictionary: Table 1: (Nos 1-98). ID RA (J2000) Dec s UCAC2 Tyc/GSC CPD CD HD V remarks 1 10 44 00.37 -59 52 27.5 U 05555197 8626-2169-1 -59 2556 -59 3279 93130 8.0 NSV 18497, NWrn of 12" pair 2 10 44 27.55 -59 53 05.5 U 05555414 8626-2254-1 -59 2577 -59 3290 93191 8.5 3 10 43 52.26 -60 07 04.0 U 50006997 8957-1556-1 -59 2548 -59 3272 93131 6.5 NSV 18488 4 10 44 05.86 -59 59 41.6 U 05555242 8626-2281-1 -59 2560 -59 3281 305520 8.7 5 10 44 11.08 -60 03 21.6 U 05303897 8957- 921-1 -59 2563 -59 3284 305536 8.9 6 10 44 36.25 -60 05 28.9 U 05304106 8957- 599-1 -59 2590 -59 3295 93222 8.1 7 10 44 45.24 -59 54 41.6 U 05555537 8626- 644-1 -59 2602 -59 3301 305524 9.3 8 10 44 14.97 -60 00 05.7 U 05303927 8957- 263-1 -59 2568 -59 3286 305522 9.7 9 10 43 49.78 -60 03 37.6 U 05303714 8957-2591-1 -59 2545 -59 3270 9.6 10 10 44 40.51 -60 03 33.3 U 05304149 8957-2655-1 -59 2599 -59 3299 9.4 11 10 44 47.52 -59 57 58.9 U 05555554 8626-2345-1 -59 2604 -59 3302 305534 9.7 12 10 44 36.78 -59 54 24.8 U 05555479 8626- 800-1 -59 2592 -59 3297 9.5 13 10 43 27.40 -60 05 54.8 U 05303492 8957- 44-1 -59 2527 -59 3257 93056 9.0 14 10 43 17.95 -60 08 03.3 U 05303411 8957- 482-1 -59 2522 -59 3255 93027 8.7 15 10 42 47.3 -60 02 39 T 05303123 8957-1190-1 -59 2507 -59 3246 305544 8.6 0".7 cpm pair, foreground dwarfs 16 10 43 49.40 -59 57 22.6 U 05555099 8626-2050-1 -59 2542 -59 3268 305521 9.8 Wrn of 15" pair 17 10 44 57.34 -59 56 06.4 U 50012567 8626-2618-1 -59 2611 -59 3305 93281 7.7 IRAS 10430-5940 18 10 44 50.42 -59 55 44.9 U 05555575 8626-1838-1 -59 2605 11.1 19 10 44 15.87 -60 09 04.4 U 05303934 8957- 265-1 -59 2570 10.5 20 10 44 15.2 -60 07 53 M 8957-2630 -59 2569 10.4 3".5 pair 21 10 43 57.49 -60 05 28.2 T 8957- 450-1 -59 2551 -59 3274 9.3 22 10 43 44.01 -59 48 17.8 U 05555052 8626- 781-1 -59 2536 -59 3266 305518 9.7 23 10 42 45.17 -59 52 19.6 U 05554593 8626-2485-1 -59 2503 -59 3244 305437 9.1 24 10 42 43.77 -59 54 16.5 U 05554583 8626-1512-1 -59 2502 -59 3243 305438 8.8 25 10 42 54.64 -59 58 19.7 U 05554669 8626-1109-1 -59 2509 -59 3248 305535 9.4 26 10 43 14.87 -60 07 46.4 U 05303379 8957-1061-1 -59 2520 10.6 27 10 43 15.34 -60 12 04.2 U 05303385 8957-1017-1 -59 2521 -59 3254 93028 8.4 28 10 43 10.07 -60 02 11.8 U 05303332 8957-1314-1 -59 2517 -59 3251 305543 9.7 DW Car 29 10 42 36.36 -60 02 34.7 U 05303012 8957-2587-1 -59 2496 -59 3240 305451 10.2 30 10 42 36.15 -59 59 26.1 U 05554536 8626-1215-1 -59 2495 -59 3239 10.8 31 10 43 15.75 -59 51 05.6 U 05554825 8626-1801-1 -59 2519 -59 3253 305516 9.9 32 10 44 29.48 -59 57 18.1 U 05555428 8626-2225-1 -59 2580 -59 3291 305523 8.5 NSV 18500 33 10 44 22.91 -59 59 36.0 T 8626-2523-1 -59 2572 -59 3287 93206 6.3 QZ Car, SErn of 1" cpm pair 34 10 44 39.51 -59 59 33.1 U 05555496 8626-1362-1 -59 2597 9.8 35 10 44 37.33 -60 00 59.5 U 05304115 8957-1243-1 -59 2594 -59 3296a 10.2 NErn of 13" pair 36 10 44 36.87 -60 01 11.7 U 05304111 8957-1318-1 -59 2593 -59 3296b 10.2 NSV 18505, SWrn of 13" pair 37 10 44 57.33 -60 00 46.8 M 8957- 362-1 -59 2614 10.8 faint comp 6" SE 38 10 45 34.05 -59 57 26.6 U 05555853 8626-1859-1 -59 2650 -59 3314 305532 10.2 39 10 44 54.71 -59 56 01.9 U 05555602 8626-1762-1 -59 2610 -59 3304 9.9 40 10 44 32.91 -59 52 53.2 U 05555454 8626-2627-1 -59 2582 10.6 41 10 44 30.08 -59 52 14.2 U 05555435 8626-2435 -59 2579 11.1 42 10 44 11.21 -59 52 42.8 U 05555278 8626-2472-1 -59 2564 10.5 not marked on chart, = TBA 115 43 10 43 45.08 -59 53 25.4 U 05555058 8626-2476-1 -59 2537 -59 3265 10.5 44 10 43 03.98 -59 51 39.1 U 05554745 8626-1808-1 -59 2513 -59 3249 305515 10.4 crowded 45 10 44 04.07 -60 00 17.3 U 05303831 8957- 591-1 -59 2559 10.2 46 10 44 56.61 -60 07 56.4 U 05304274 8957-1491-1 -59 2612 305542 10.7 47 10 45 13.37 -59 57 53.8 U 05555717 8626-1802-1 -59 2639 305533 10.3 NSV 18513 48 10 43 48.87 -60 09 00.8 U 05303706 8957-3949-1 -59 2543 11.0 49 10 42 46.17 -60 00 57.6 U 05303115 8957-2280-1 -59 2504 11.2 50 10 44 09.74 -60 00 43.3 U 05303887 8957-0648 12.0 51 10 44 14.44 -60 01 27.0 U 05303921 8957-2320-1 11.9 52 10 44 08.72 -59 58 23.0 M 8626-2037 12.5 53 10 43 51.35 -59 57 19.6 U 05555115 8626-1994-1 -59 2547 -59 3271 10.9 Ern of 15" pair 54 10 43 48.09 -59 56 13.6 M 8626-1886 12.7 55 10 43 39.77 -59 55 16.6 U 05555013 8626-0989 -59 2533 -59 3263 11.7 56 10 43 58.44 -59 56 09.5 U 05555176 13.4 57 10 44 11.25 -59 55 30.7 U 05555279 8626-1898-1 -59 2562 -59 3283 305519 9.9 NWrn of 15" pair 58 10 44 12.92 -59 55 39.3 U 05555297 8626-0066 12.7 SErn of 15" pair 59 10 44 05.3 -59 53 36 M 05555238 8626-0929 12.9 4" pair 60 10 44 02.38 -59 52 04.6 U 05555218 8626-1915 12.7 61 10 44 01.00 -59 52 38.8 U 05555204 11.7 SErn of 12" pair 62 10 44 25.43 -60 03 29.9 M 8957-2954 12.7 63 10 44 28.65 -60 02 40.1 U 05304052 13.6 64 10 44 13.94 -60 02 58.2 U 05303917 8957-1361 12.9 65 10 44 00.16 -60 05 09.9 U 05303801 8957-3079-1 -59 2555a -59 3274a 93146 8.4 NErn of 6" pair 66 10 43 59.45 -60 05 13.3 M 8957-4264-1 -59 2555b -59 3274b 9.8 SWrn of 6" pair 67 10 44 00.43 -60 06 00.0 U 05303804 8957- 356-1 -59 2554a -59 3278a 8.8 NErn of 8" pair, also closer comp 68 10 44 00.13 -60 06 07.5 M -59 2554b -59 3278b 10.2 SWrn of 8" pair 69 10 43 46.98 -60 05 49.3 U 05303681 8957- 506-1 -59 2540a -59 3267a 93097 9.8 NErn of 10" pair 70 10 43 46.21 -60 05 57.4 U 05303673 8957-4265-1 -59 2540b -59 3267b 10.8 SWrn of 10" pair 71 10 43 32.05 -60 05 06.7 U 05303539 8957-0819 11.4 72 10 43 28.67 -60 05 27.3 U 05303505 13.3 73 10 43 26.72 -60 05 12.7 M 8957-1070 12.9 74 10 43 46.79 -60 08 26.5 U 05303678 8957-1260 -59 2539 11.7 75 10 43 50.00 -60 01 54.4 U 05303718 8957- 403-1 -59 2546 11.2 76 10 43 47.97 -60 01 20.1 U 05303693 8957-1436 12.4 77 10 43 48.82 -60 00 36.7 U 05303702 8957- 822-1 -59 2541 11.6 78 10 43 31.55 -60 03 16.1 U 05303534 8957-0460 -59 2530 -59 3260 11.4 79 10 44 43.33 -60 02 05.4 U 05304167 8957-1080 11.1 80 10 45 16.73 -59 54 45.8 U 05555736 8626-2459 -59 2642 -59 3311 305528 10.3 81 10 45 53.46 -60 05 37.1 U 05304668 8957-1177 -59 2660 10.9 82 10 45 46.45 -60 05 13.3 U 05304619 8957- 671-1 -59 2655 305538 10.5 83 10 45 44.40 -60 04 23.3 U 05304600 8957- 733-1 -59 2653 305537 10.7 84 10 45 38.67 -60 04 25.9 U 05304569 8957-1746 -59 2652 11.1 85 10 45 34.1 -60 04 31 U 05304548 8957-2515 -59 2651 11.2 8" trio 86 10 45 45.03 -60 06 31.1 U 05304606 8957-0912 -59 2654 11.1 87 10 45 32.20 -60 06 16.7 U 05304531 8957-0195 -59 2649 305541 10.6 crowded 88 10 45 51.82 -60 11 32.7 U 05304653 8957-1990-1 -59 2659 -59 3315 93421 8.8 89 10 47 13.17 -60 13 33.8 U 05305127 8957-3819-1 -59 2698 10.4 90 10 47 20.49 -60 12 57.1 U 05305187 8957-2997-1 -59 2703 -59 3331 93647 9.4 91 10 47 11.49 -60 11 47.0 U 05305111 8957-2972-1 -59 2697 305540 10.1 92 10 47 12.63 -60 05 50.8 U 05305125 8957-1512-1 -59 2696 -59 3328 93632 8.4 93 10 46 53.84 -60 04 41.9 U 05305007 8957-1544-1 -59 2687 -59 3325 93576 9.6 2" pair 94 10 46 33.06 -60 04 12.6 U 05304902 8957- 939-1 -59 2680 -59 3322 305539 9.9 95 10 46 25.42 -60 08 43.7 U 05304867 8957-2018-1 -59 2674 11.0 96 10 46 22.04 -60 01 18.9 U 05304848 8957-1997-1 -59 2672 -59 3319 93501 9.1 97 10 46 22.47 -59 53 20.5 U 05556135 8626-1530-1 -59 2673 10.4 98 10 46 05.71 -59 50 49.4 U 05556038 8626-1634-1 -59 2665 -59 3316 305525 10.0 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- source: 1980MNRAS.192..283T TURNER D.G. and MOFFAT A.F.J. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 192, 283-296 (1980) Anomalous extinction in the Carina Nebula ? ID RA (J2000) Dec s UCAC2 Tyc/GSC CPD CD HD V remarks 100 10 42 10.27 -59 57 57.7 M -59 2479b -59 3236b 10.4 Nrn of 3".5 pair 101 10 42 45.32 -60 12 06.3 M 11.1 SWrn of 10" quartet 102 10 42 46.26 -60 12 02.1 M 11.3 NErn of 10" quartet 103 10 42 46.54 -60 12 07.0 M 11.0 SErn of 10" quartet 104 10 43 48.87 -60 06 43.8 U 05303705 8957- 480-1 11.7 105 10 43 54.79 -60 06 20.9 U 05303761 8957-3682-1 12.1 106 10 43 53.71 -60 06 43.3 M 8957-0739 13.3 107 10 43 58.44 -60 07 43.7 M 8957-1885 12.8 108 10 44 00.51 -60 07 22.3 M 13.1 109 10 44 01.05 -60 06 37.8 U 05303809 8957-0249 12.9 110 10 44 03.10 -60 06 21.7 U 05303823 8957-1785 12.8 111 10 43 57.22 -60 05 00.7 M 8957-1977 13.1 112 10 43 59.11 -60 03 34.5 M 8957-0106 11.5 113 10 44 31.74 -60 05 44.9 U 05304072 8957- 174-1 -59 2585 -59 3292 11.4 114 10 44 38.30 -60 05 44.9 M 05304121 8957- 65-1 12.3 Ern of 4".5 pair 115 10 44 35.48 -59 59 54.0 U 05555469 8626-1827 -59 2588 11.4 NSV 18504 116 10 44 11.21 -59 52 42.8 U 05555278 8626-2472-1 -59 2564 10.5 foreground G dwarf Name RA (J2000) Dec s UCAC2 Tyc/GSC CPD CD HD V remarks LS 1776 10 42 02.30 -60 08 38.6 U 05302626 8957- 130-1 -59 2476 -59 3232 305452 9.5 LS 1780 10 42 10.33 -59 58 01.0 U 05554335 8626-1448-1 -59 2479a -59 3236a 305439 9.6 NSV 18481, Srn of 3".5 pair LS 1782 10 42 10.14 -60 14 38.4 U 05302714 8957-3039-1 -59 2480 -59 3235 305455 10.1 LS 1794 10 42 45.52 -60 12 01.3 U 05303107 8957- 227-1 -59 2505 -59 3245 305453 9.7 NWrn of 10" quartet LS 1800 10 43 11.18 -59 44 21.0 U 05554794 8626-2607-1 -59 2518 -59 3252 303316 9.6 NWrn of 11" pair LS 1811 10 43 43.40 -60 20 27.5 U 05303646 8957- 475-1 -59 2538 -59 3264 305556 8.8 LS 1883 10 45 53.72 -59 57 03.8 U 05555957 8626-1572 -59 2661 11.3 NSV 4968, in nebula IRAS 10439-5941 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- source: 1980A&AS...41...93T THE P.S., BAKKER R., and ANTALOVA A. Astron. Astrophys., Suppl. Ser., 41, 93-107 (1980) Studies of the Carina Nebula: IV. A new determination of the distances of the open clusters Tr 14, Tr 15, and Cr 228 based on Walraven photometry. Dictionary: Table IV: (Nos 100-119) added. ID RA (J2000) Dec s UCAC2 Tyc/GSC CPD CD HD V remarks 100 10 44 25.35 -60 12 45.9 U 05304018 8957- 489-1 -59 2575 -59 3289 93192 9.3 101 10 43 05.25 -59 52 42.9 U 05554751 8626-2413-1 -59 2514 305517 11.0 102 10 44 35.48 -59 59 54.0 U 05555469 8626-1827 -59 2588 11.4 NSV 18504 = TM 115 103 10 45 13.5 -60 00 59 U 05304395 8957-1761 -59 2638 11.4 2" pair 104 10 45 05.79 -60 03 24.3 U 05304347 8957-1548 12.0 105 10 44 58.11 -60 04 50.3 U 05304284 8957-0706 11.8 106 10 44 31.74 -60 05 44.9 U 05304072 8957- 174-1 -59 2585 -59 3292 11.4 = TM 113 107 10 43 56.56 -60 12 00.8 U 05303777 8957-1285-1 -59 2550 -59 3273 9.4 108 10 43 40.81 -60 10 03.2 U 05303624 8957-1385-1 -59 2535 10.9 109 10 44 16.79 -60 04 36.0 U 05303944 8957-3193 11.8 110 10 43 59.11 -60 03 34.5 M 8957-0106 11.5 = TM 112 111 10 44 50.56 -59 57 22.6 U 05555576 8626- 883-1 12.3 112 10 45 04.29 -59 54 35.5 U 05555658 8626-0957 11.9 113 10 44 57.54 -59 54 29.6 U 05555617 8626-1887 11.6 [AMM2003] 45 114 10 44 43.03 -59 53 48.7 U 05555523 8626-1931-1 -59 2601 11.4 115 10 44 11.21 -59 52 42.8 U 05555278 8626-2472-1 -59 2564 10.5 = TM 116 116 10 43 25.83 -59 52 48.5 U 05554915 8626-0457 11.2 117 10 43 20.05 -59 56 43.5 U 05554860 8626-2112 -59 2524 11.4 118 10 44 53.52 -59 51 54.0 U 05555592 8626-2581-1 -59 2607 11.4 119 10 44 58.79 -59 49 21.0 U 05555627 8626-1983 -59 2617 11.7 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Cross-identifications Fein MJ Carraro 1 208 2 325 7 404 11 413 12 366 15 1 16 151 17 459 18 420 22 117 28 2 29 3 30 4 31 36 32 336 38 593 39 449 40 347 41 333 42 253 43 126 44 4 47 529 49 5 52 249 53 167 54 145 55 101 56 204 57 258 58 264 59 234 60 222 61 216 80 543 97 691 98 661 TM MJ TM 116 253 LS 1800 22 LS 1883 632 The' MJ Cudworth 101 8 111 422 112 482 113 458 114 388 115 253 116 59 117 46 118 435 119 462 Y273