There is a modest mess in SIMBAD for the field of the cluster Collinder 258 = Harvard 5. The brighter stars have Tycho-based coordinates, but the remainder have only approximate ones. Brent Archinal has gone through the exercise of sorting out the bogus historical positions for the three clusters in the area, and SIMBAD/WEBDA are basically correct in this nomenclature. Note, however, that the Lynga source position is bad, and should be replaced as given below. There are three sets of photometry for the field. The main list in M&V III is given first in the usual format. There are no serious problems, although the present SIMBAD identity of CPD-60 3999 (adopted from M&V) is probably wrong. See the note for star 8 about this. Next I show coordinates for Seggewiss' stars in the field, which are mostly outside the group observed by M&V. The four stars in common with M&V are correctly identified in SIMBAD. Since his photometry is not present for the remainder, I include it in the second list. Note that the V magnitudes for M&V star 24 = Seggewiss 12 differ considerably; perhaps it is variable. Finally, I noticed SIMBAD shows five stars with names "HD 108353 x", where 'x' is a letter A-E. These are from a study by Loden assessing the group as a multiple star. I do not have access to this paper (the Lowell library gave up on 'Astrophysics & Space Science' in the mid-80s due its high cost and lack of citations), but the photometry shown in the SIMBAD headers for these stars matches unambiguously with five bright stars measured by M&V. The SIMBAD positions (adopted from Loden's paper?) are simply wrong, perhaps from a precession error---though the infamous and ubiquitous typos in Ap&SS may plague this paper, too. (In fact the relative offsets are consistent, so it's probably a precession error---assumed to be 1975, when they are actually 1950, or some such.) Anyway, V and B-V match within ~0.02 in each case, so I think these can be linked as indicated. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Coordinates and identifications for stars in Collinder 258 = Harvard 5 version: 4 Dec 2003: V mags added for M&V stars and Loden data 2 Dec 2001 source: 1973A&AS...10..135M cluster center = HD 108353: 12 27 16 -60 46.8 (J2000) position sources (column 's'): G GSC-ACT (1999GSCTy.C......0G, I/255) g GSC-2.2 (2001GSC2..C......0S, I/271) U UCAC1 (2000AJ....120.2131Z, I/268) Name RA (J2000) Dec s GSC Tycho-2 V remarks 1* 12 27 16.42 -60 50 11.5 U 8975-2369 8975-2369-1 9.0 CPD-60 3997 2 12 26 52.35 -60 45 13.9 U 8975-2133 8975-2133-1 9.4 HD 108295 3* 12 27 02.12 -60 45 16.2 U 8975-2147 8975-2147-1 9.7 CPD-60 3993 4 12 27 22.42 -60 44 55.7 U 8975-1425 8975-1425-1 11.4 CPD-60 4004 5* 12 27 24.73 -60 45 48.1 U 8975-3213 8975-3213-1 10.5 CPD-60 4005 6 12 27 26.58 -60 46 29.0 G 8975-2395 12.5 7 12 27 15.45 -60 47 56.2 U 8975-2191 8975-2191-1 11.6 CPD-60 3999 8* 12 27 16.19 -60 47 37.5 U 8975-2627 8975-2627-1 11.8 9 12 27 19.01 -60 47 24.2 U 8975-1961 8975-1961-1 12.1 CPD-60 4002 10 12 27 22.65 -60 47 43.4 U 8975-3193 11.5 11 12 27 16.93 -60 45 41.7 U 8975-2227 12.2 12* 12 27 16.00 -60 46 16.4 U 8975-3509 8975-3509-1 10.1 CPD-60 4000 13 12 27 16.57 -60 46 32.9 U 8975-4108 8975-4108-1 10.9 14* 12 27 16.30 -60 46 45.5 U 8975-3373 8975-3373-1 8.4 HD 108353 15 12 27 11.99 -60 47 07.1 U 8975-1857 12.5 16* 12 27 05.87 -60 47 12.2 U 8975-3005 8975-3005-1 12.5 17 12 27 04.81 -60 47 08.2 g 12.7 18 12 27 03.40 -60 47 00.0 G 8975-3407 12.6 19* 12 27 34.05 -60 44 36.4 U 8975-2901 8975-2901-1 11.2 CPD-60 4007 20 12 27 38.81 -60 44 57.7 U 8975-2075 8975-2075-1 12.3 21* 12 27 51.73 -60 44 56.8 U 8975-2561 8975-2561-1 9.9 CPD-60 4012 22 12 27 23.00 -60 47 12.9 U 13.2 23 12 27 11.28 -60 46 04.7 U 8975-1789 13.0 24 12 27 05.09 -60 45 59.1 U 8975-2232 13.2 25 12 27 11.74 -60 46 34.7 g 13.6 Notes 1 CD-60 4173 = MSX5C G299.9906+01.8968. 3 MSX5C G299.9540+01.9751. 5 CD-60 4176. 8 probably not CPD-60 3999: star 7 is closer to nominal position, and is slightly brighter in B. 12 CD-60 4175. 14 CD-60 4174 = NSV 19393 = HD 108353 A. position for brighter of pair; M&V photometry for combined light. 16 Tycho-1 position erroneous. 19 CD-60 4178 = GSPC S131-R. 21 CD-60 4183 = GSPC S131-Q. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Seggewiss [Harvard 5] (1971VeBon..83...19S) SIMBAD nomenclature: (Nos 1-24) Segge RA (J2000) Dec s GSC V B-V remarks 4 12 27 16.42 -60 50 11.5 U 8975-2369 9.01 1.44 CPD-60 3997 6 12 27 51.73 -60 44 56.8 U 8975-2561 9.89 0.03 CPD-60 4012 7 12 27 34.05 -60 44 36.4 U 8975-2901 11.23 0.21 CPD-60 4007 8* 12 27 02.23 -60 42 44.1 U 8975-1549 11.37 1.08 9* 12 27 13.99 -60 43 43.6 U 8975-3377 12.13 0.19 12* 12 27 05.09 -60 45 59.1 U 8975-2232 12.97 0.28 14 12 27 13.71 -60 49 09.4 U 13.02 1.36 15 12 27 42.05 -60 47 15.5 U 8975-2695 13.03 0.31 16 12 27 09.47 -60 44 32.0 U 13.68 0.37 17* 12 27 46.29 -60 46 41.6 U 13.69 2.27 18 12 27 06.31 -60 48 24.3 U 13.75 0.55 19 12 27 03.97 -60 49 07.8 g 13.75 0.59 20 12 27 06.58 -60 42 42.8 U 14.02 0.61 22 12 27 37.16 -60 46 40.4 U 14.64 0.68 24 12 27 03.05 -60 48 09.1 U 14.84 0.77 Notes 8 TYC 8975-1549-1. 9 TYC 8975-3377-1. 12 Cl Collinder 258 24. 17 MSX5C G300.0445+01.9604. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Loden IDs (1993Ap&SS.199..165L) coords in this paper are completely wrong Names V B-V spec HD 108353 A = HD 108353 8.44 0.07 B7.5 HD 108353 B = Cl Collinder 258 13 10.90 0.07 B7.8 HD 108353 C = CPD-60 4000 10.07 0.09 B8.0 HD 108353 D = CPD-60 4005 10.48 0.10 B8.4 HD 108353 E = CPD-60 4004 11.44 0.13 B9.0