Photometry of the stellar group Dolidze-Dzimsheleshvili 8 version: 7 Feb 2000 (Tycho-2 motions for stars) 18 Jan 2000 (revision of motions using H/T and ACT data) 3 Jan 1995 (text/tables slightly revised to include slight reddening) Abstract V magnitudes and Stromgren (b-y) colours have been measured for the sparse group DoDz 8 in Hercules. The photometry and proper motions for the six candidate members indicate this is not a physical cluster. Introduction Users of the Uranometria 2000.0 atlas have noticed the presence of a large number of clusters in the northern sky with the designations "Do" or "DoDz". These objects were reported by the Georgian astronomers M. V. Dolidze and G. N. Dzimsheleshvili of the Abastumani Astrophysical Observatory. Upon visual inspection, these groups are found in most cases to be merely a few relatively bright stars, lacking the large number of fainter members exhibited by bona fide open clusters---they are not even interesting telescopic objects. An example of such an object is DoDz 8 (ref. 1), located in Hercules near delta Herculis on Uranometria chart 158. The chart shows six mag. 9 stars superposed on the circle indicating the cluster. Visual observation shows that these are the only stars in the cluster over the moderately-rich background field at intermediate galactic latitude. Photometry I made photometric observations of these six stars (plus one additional fainter one) using the Lowell 53cm photometric telescope. The single-channel photometer contains Stromgren filters, which are narrower than the more common broadband Johnson filters. The Stromgren y filter corresponds closely to Johnson V, and measures with this filter are transformed to V. The Stromgren b-y colour gives an indication of stellar temperatures, as does Johnson B-V. The stars were observed on the night of 22 May 1994 UT, a night with bright Moonlight, which was not important for these fairly bright stars. Over two dozen primary and secondary standard stars were observed during the course of the night; the cluster stars formed only a portion of the program stars. The instrumental magnitudes for the standards were transformed to the standard system by means of linear equations; extinction coefficients were determined at the beginning of the night. The mean rms residuals for the standards from this fit were 0.008 and 0.007 mag. in V and b-y, respectively. The results for the program stars, although observed on only one night, are likely to be reliable to within about +/-0.01 mag. Discussion In preparation for the observations, I looked up each of the bright stars in the SIMBAD database. All the stars appear in various traditional star catalogues, such as the BD and HD catalogues. Importantly, they also are contained in modern astrometric catalogues, so that reliable proper motions exist for all the stars. I also made a plot of the field using the Guide Star Catalogue. This allowed me to determine an improved position for the center of the group: DoDz 8: 17 26 24 +24 11.6 (J2000) which is a few arcminutes different from the one reported by the discoverers. The diameter of the cluster is simply the separation of the widest pair of stars: 14'. This matches the size reported in the original publication. The combined magnitude of the seven stars for which I obtained photometry is V = 6.83. Table 1 summarizes the available information about the stars. The first few columns show star names, J2000 positions, and proper motions for the stars drawn from star catalogues. The units of the proper motions (pma = proper motion in Right Ascension; pmd = proper motion in Declination) are in milliarcseconds per year; the uncertainties are about +/-5 milliarcsec/year in each case. All of the motions are very small, being hardly different from zero for four of the six stars. The columns V and b-y show my photometric results, followed by spectral types for the stars from the literature, and a few remarks. The IRAS identification had evidently not been made previously. Figure 1 shows the field of the cluster from the GSC, including all the stars. It is probably complete to around mag. 13, but shows stars as faint as mag. 15. One can see instantly the complete lack of any concentration of fainter background stars in the vicinity of the supposed cluster, a first indication that it is not real. Since the field is well away from the Milky Way, the stars are likely to be unreddened, or nearly so, by interstellar dust. The reddening maps of Burstein & Heiles (1982) indicate a maximum reddening of E(B-V) 0.09. In the analysis that follows, I have arbitrarily assumed half this value, which corresponds to E(b-y) = 0.03 in the Stromgren system, and A(V) = 0.12. This amount of color excess does about the least damage to the published spectral types. The intrinsic colors and photometric spectral type predictions are listed in Table 2 along with assumed absolute magnitudes and distances for each star. The uncertainties involved in the last two items are substantial, at least 30%, and more likely 50%. This results not from the uncertainty in the photometry but instead from our simply not knowing how intrinsically bright different types of stars really are. Similar errors could occur if, for instance, the A-type stars are giants instead of dwarfs, which would put them at least half again more distant. I have thus "rounded" the distances to the nearest 25 parsec increment. The photometry and proper motions suggest that the three brighter A-type stars are at roughly the same distance, in the range 175 to 250 parsecs. But the typical open cluster is only a few parsecs diameter, so these are hardly close enough to form a bound group. The fainter F8 and G0 stars both have significant motion (in opposite directions!), and their magnitudes indicate they must be very much in the foreground if (as is probable) they are dwarf stars. The spectrum of the F8 star is slightly metal-poor according to Bidelman (ref. 2). The b-y colour of the G0 star suggests a rather later spectral type, about K0. Because these stars are so faint intrinsically, it must lie only about 50 parsecs away, and thus the reddening has been assumed to be zero in this case only. The K2 star is almost certainly a giant, to judge from its b-y colour and negligible proper motion, so its apparent magnitude places it well in the background of the A stars, around 400 parsecs away. The additional fainter star, identified only in the GSC, is a mid-F star from its b-y colour, located some 300 parsecs away. Thus DoDz 8 is merely a chance alignment of stars spread over a large range of distances along the line of sight, such as is commonly found in any randomly-chosen field of the sky. Acknowledgement This report was facilitated by use of the on-line database SIMBAD, maintained by the Centre de Donnees astronomiques, Strasbourg, France. >>> positions and motions are Tycho-2 <<< Table 1. Astrometry and photometry for stars in DoDz 8 Name RA (2000) Dec pmA pmD V b-y spec remarks BD+24 3180 17 25 54.61 +24 15 22.1 3 -11 9.53 0.20 A7 BD+24 3181 17 26 13.78 +24 08 04.7 -14 -1 8.36 0.12 A2 HD 158085 BD+24 3182 17 26 17.09 +24 05 20.4 4 3 8.48 0.07 A2 HD 158099 BD+24 3183 17 26 16.62 +24 16 03.2 28 -13 9.44 0.47 G0 prob dK0 BD+24 3184 17 26 19.37 +24 17 52.2 -8 3 8.26 0.78 K2 see note BD+24 3185 17 26 54.24 +24 12 39.8 -39 64 9.69 0.33 F8wl GSC 2074-0972 17 25 44.07 +24 06 39.7 7 -13 10.79 0.29 (f2/5) Note BD+24 3184 = IRAS 17242+2420. Table 2. "Derived" data for the stars predicted Name (b-y)o spec Mv r(pc) HIP (pc) BD+24 3180 0.17 f0v 2.6 225 275 BD+24 3181 0.09 a5/7v 2.3 150 BD+24 3182 0.04 a2v 1.4 250 BD+24 3183 0.47 k0v 5.9 50 BD+24 3184 0.75 k2iii 0.1 400 BD+24 3185 0.30 f5/7v 3.5 150 125pc if F8 GSC 2074-0972 0.26 f2/5v 3.2 300 References: 1. Dolidze, M. V. and Dzimsheleshvili, G. N. 1966. New Possible Star Clusters. Astronomical Circulars, (Moscow) no. 382. 2. Bidelman, W. 1985. Objective-prism Discoveries in the Northern Sky. II. Astron. J., 90, 341.