The lists below show accurate coordinates and basic identifications for stars observed by three authors in the field of IC 4725 = Messier 25. Omitted (for now) are stars observed photographically in a wider field by Landolt (1964ApJS....8..352L) and at the cluster center by van den Bergh; I have identified vdB's photoelectric sequence stars, however. I compared screen plots of UCAC2 against the charts in all three papers to get coordinates. BD and CPD names were determined 'ab initio' using paper plots of each catalogue overlain on enlarged photocopies of these charts. Because the numbering schemes by Sandage and by Johnson are somewhat different, despite having been derived from the same unpublished chart by Irwin, I derived the star-lists independently and show them separately below. N.B. Sandage star 185 is not identified anywhere, so that entry is left blank; it is present with no coordinates in SIMBAD and WEBDA). Arlo Landolt (visiting Lowell at present) may have the original Irwin chart, and thus star 185 could be recoverable. I have not compared the lists with SIMBAD star-by-star. It will be seen that there are some mix-ups in nomenclature, bad coordinates, etc. An example is 'IC 4725 200', a name which belongs to none of the lists here. It is shown in SIMBAD with V=10.08, B-V=0.38, and coordinates very close to those for BD-19 5049 = CPD-19 6909. However, notice also that the star called 'BD-19 5044J' in SIMBAD has identical UBV data but different coordinates (those of CPD-19 6902). In contrast with such ambiguities, all the Wampler et al stars (1961ApJ...133..895W) that have approximate coordinates can now be matched with existing stars and have coordinates corrected, which will clean up many mutiple entries in SIMBAD. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Stars in Messier 25 = IC 4725 version: 6 Oct 2006, correction from FWoelfel (CDS) 29 Sep 2006 position sources (column 's'): D DENIS (1999A&A...349..236E, b/denis) M 2MASS (2006AJ....131.1163S, II/246) T Tycho-2 (2000A&A...357..367H, I/259) U UCAC2 (2004AJ....127.3043Z, I/289) Sandage stars in Messier 25 source: 1960ApJ...131..610S SANDAGE A. Astrophys. J., 131, 610-619 (1960) Cepheids in galactic clusters. VI. U Sgr in M25. Comments: Table 1: Numbering from an Irwin chart. Dictionary: Table 1: N=81 among (Nos 29-185). ID RA (J2000) Dec s V UCAC2 Tyc/GSC BD CPD remarks 29 18 31 23.13 -19 01 33.4 U 12.1 24437540 6274-1483 30 18 31 21.25 -19 02 13.1 U 12.4 24437518 6274-1263 31 18 31 19.27 -19 03 11.1 U 10.7 24437485 6274-1334-1 -19 6879 46 18 31 31.06 -19 14 57.0 U 11.8 24437653 6274-1166-1 47 18 31 32.10 -19 14 30.8 U 11.4 24437662 6274-1144 50 18 31 24.21 -19 09 31.0 U 8.0 24437555 6274-1190-1 -19 5036 -19 6881 HD 170682 51 18 31 28.08 -19 09 02.8 U 9.2 24437604 6274-1201-1 -19 5037 -19 6882 52 18 31 29.97 -19 09 43.3 U 12.5 24437632 6274-1432 53 18 31 33.75 -19 09 40.3 U 14.0 24437686 54 18 31 37.21 -19 10 10.2 U 10.5 24437724 6274-1395-1 -19 6890 55 18 31 35.21 -19 09 27.9 M 14.3 NWrn of 5" pair 56 18 31 36.58 -19 08 34.8 U 11.7 24437715 6274-1655-1 60 18 31 32.48 -19 08 20.4 U 14.1 24437668 61 18 31 30.32 -19 08 15.6 U 13.1 24437638 62 18 31 34.80 -19 06 41.2 U 13.7 24437701 63 18 31 31.76 -19 06 05.4 U 11.9 24437657 6274-1650-1 64 18 31 31.2 -19 05 43 M 11.7 6274-1364 3" pair 67 18 31 23.24 -19 04 26.7 U 10.4 24437542 6274-1538-1 -19 6880 68 18 31 27.43 -19 04 10.5 U 12.8 24437595 6274-1274 81 18 31 51.24 -19 00 49.6 U 12.7 24437937 6274-1555 82 18 31 48.63 -19 01 21.5 U 13.6 24437888 83 18 31 50.66 -19 01 59.0 U 13.0 24437928 84 18 31 52.99 -19 03 21.4 U 11.7 24437959 6274-1294 85 18 31 40.96 -19 02 10.6 U 12.1 24437777 6274-1129 86 18 31 38.95 -19 03 01.5 M 12.8 87 18 31 49.58 -19 03 17.3 U 13.8 24437905 88 18 31 44.72 -19 03 37.8 U 13.2 24437840 89 18 31 42.84 -19 04 08.7 U 12.2 24437802 90 18 31 40.26 -19 04 43.7 U 12.1 24437764 6274-1513 91 18 31 37.55 -19 05 18.9 T 8.1 6274-1299-1 -19 5042 -19 6892 HD 170719 92 18 31 37.54 -19 06 14.2 U 11.2 24437729 6274-1117 93 18 31 45.01 -19 05 23.5 U 10.4 24437843 6274-1159-1 -19 6901 94 18 31 43.09 -19 05 39.7 U 12.2 24437805 6274-1170-1 95 18 31 41.12 -19 06 09.6 U 12.2 24437778 96 18 31 41.63 -19 06 53.3 U 9.7 24437785 6274-1658-1 -19 6895 97 18 31 43.31 -19 07 02.1 U 8.8 24437809 6274-1479-1 -19 5044 -19 6896 98 18 31 44.56 -19 07 13.6 U 10.2 24437837 6274-1181-1 -19 6897 NSV 24486 99 18 31 44.26 -19 06 34.7 U 9.9 24437834 6274-1379-1 -19 6898 100 18 31 46.33 -19 06 31.4 U 10.1 24437860 6274-1161 -19 6902 101 18 31 48.72 -19 07 00.0 U 10.3 24437889 6274-1427-1 -19 6903 102 18 31 48.9 -19 07 51 T 9.3 24437893 6274-1447-1 -19 6904 Hen 3-1707 (B8:e), 0".9 cpm pair 103 18 31 53.33 -19 07 30.3 T 6.7 6274-1601-1 -19 5047 -19 6907 U Sgr = HD 170764 104 18 31 50.89 -19 05 01.5 U 13.3 24437933 106 18 31 58.76 -19 07 30.0 U 11.2 24438030 6274-1189 NErn of 6" pair (comp red) 107 18 31 59.4 -19 06 46 U 14.5 24438036 NSV 10962, crowded 108 18 31 58.46 -19 06 11.9 M 14.1 109 18 32 02.38 -19 05 33.2 U 10.1 24438074 6275- 21-1 -19 5049 -19 6909 110 18 32 02.39 -19 07 14.2 U 14.8 24438075 111 18 32 03.75 -19 07 55.6 U 14.4 24438093 112 18 31 52.38 -19 10 36.9 U 12.3 24437951 6274-1140 114 18 31 55.37 -19 10 33.3 U 11.5 24437988 6274-1403 115 18 31 46.33 -19 09 34.9 U 10.7 24437859 6274-1452-1 -19 6900 118 18 31 43.72 -19 11 24.5 U 13.9 24437818 119 18 31 41.84 -19 12 12.6 U 12.3 24437788 6274-1210 120 18 31 37.80 -19 12 06.8 U 10.6 24437734 6274-1458-1 -19 6891 121 18 31 40.17 -19 12 42.5 U 14.7 24437763 122 18 31 42.03 -19 13 04.9 U 11.8 24437792 6274-1345-1 131 18 31 53.75 -19 15 21.6 U 11.1 24437967 6274-1646-1 not double? 132 18 32 01.88 -19 14 12.6 U 13.6 24438068 133 18 32 02.03 -19 12 32.4 U 13.7 24438070 134 18 32 00.70 -19 11 45.4 U 13.7 24438054 135 18 31 50.81 -19 12 26.4 U 11.0 24437931 6274-1567 136 18 31 50.91 -19 12 05.3 M 11.6 6274-1280-1 137 18 31 52.64 -19 11 48.9 U 12.7 24437953 138 18 31 55.74 -19 10 55.9 U 13.2 24437996 141 18 31 52.92 -19 10 24.7 U 12.5 24437958 142 18 31 50.54 -19 10 10.3 U 9.0 24437924 6274-1331-1 -19 5046 -19 6905 144 18 32 04.55 -19 03 49.6 U 13.0 24438107 145 18 32 02.71 -19 05 06.0 M 13.7 147 18 32 07.12 -19 08 06.5 U 12.9 24438145 148 18 32 05.34 -19 08 50.4 U 13.2 24438120 149 18 32 05.20 -19 10 06.1 U 10.4 24438117 6275- 777-1 -19 6910 150 18 32 13.11 -19 07 26.2 U 7.4 24438243 6275- 63-1 -19 5053 -19 6915 HD 170820 157 18 32 11.41 -19 10 33.0 U 11.9 24438213 6275-0405 159 18 32 11.12 -19 11 10.4 U 10.2 24438209 6275- 317-1 -19 5050 -19 6912 160 18 32 13.60 -19 11 43.9 U 13.5 24438251 161 18 32 17.70 -19 10 49.3 U 11.8 24438306 6275-0931 164 18 32 12.09 -19 14 45.6 U 12.2 24438227 165 18 32 03.88 -19 15 10.5 U 13.6 24438099 175 18 32 21.12 -19 12 21.3 U 12.5 24438352 185 star not identified Y 18 32 19.47 -19 11 25.1 U 14.2 24438322 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Johnson stars in Messier 25 source: 1960ApJ...131..620J JOHNSON H.L. Astrophys. J., 131, 620-622 (1960) The galactic cluster M25 = IC 4725. Dictionary: Table 1: N=131 among (Nos 1-160) errata for U Sgr data: 1961ApJ...133..732J ID RA (J2000) Dec s V UCAC2 Tyc/GSC BD CPD remarks 1 18 30 22.17 -19 21 59.9 U 9.0 24436575 6274-1473-1 -19 5030 -19 6867 HD 170475 3 18 30 52.74 -19 21 14.7 U 10.1 24437085 6274-1289-1 -19 6873 4 18 30 44.62 -19 23 16.1 U 10.4 24436937 6274-1300-1 -19 5033 -19 6872 6 18 30 40.92 -19 02 21.9 U 9.6 24436880 6274-1317-1 -19 5032 -19 6871 7 18 30 58.22 -19 14 47.8 U 10.4 24437173 6274-1265-1 -19 6874 8 18 30 54.96 -19 08 54.2 U 11.5 24437119 6274-1554 10 18 31 02.26 -19 08 23.4 U 10.9 24437230 6274-1478-1 -19 6875 15 18 31 08.37 -19 09 35.8 U 12.0 24437326 6274-1095 17 18 31 10.08 -19 07 33.8 U 10.6 24437355 6274-1405-1 -19 6877 18 18 31 07.32 -19 06 14.2 U 10.2 24437308 6274-1207-1 -19 5034 -19 6876 22 18 31 07.76 -18 59 51.0 U 11.6 24683764 6274-1387 23 18 31 10.37 -19 00 01.3 U 12.2 24437356 6274-1253-1 24 18 31 09.66 -19 14 30.1 U 10.9 24437347 6274-1228-1 26 18 31 18.96 -18 54 31.7 T 6.8 6274-1576-1 -18 4986 -18 414 HD 170657, lg pm 29 18 31 23.13 -19 01 33.4 U 12.1 24437540 6274-1483 30 18 31 21.25 -19 02 13.1 U 12.4 24437518 6274-1263 40 18 31 20.65 -19 18 00.5 U 12.6 24437509 41 18 31 20.47 -19 18 42.8 U 11.8 24437504 6274-1581 42 18 31 28.91 -19 18 47.3 U 9.7 24437618 6274-1393-1 -19 5039 -19 6884 43 18 31 25.79 -19 17 08.6 U 12.6 24437580 6274-1565 44 18 31 33.97 -19 16 00.7 U 10.2 24437691 6274-1593-1 -19 6889 45 18 31 30.75 -19 15 52.6 U 10.4 24437645 6274-1288-1 -19 6886 46 18 31 31.06 -19 14 57.0 U 11.8 24437653 6274-1166-1 47 18 31 32.10 -19 14 30.8 U 11.4 24437662 6274-1144 48 18 31 33.26 -19 14 04.3 U 11.6 24437681 6274-1474-1 49 18 31 28.34 -19 14 15.3 U 9.1 24437607 6274-1625-1 -19 5038 IRAS 18285-1916 50 18 31 24.21 -19 09 31.0 U 8.0 24437555 6274-1190-1 -19 5036 -19 6881 HD 170682 51 18 31 28.08 -19 09 02.8 U 9.2 24437604 6274-1201-1 -19 5037 -19 6882 54 18 31 29.97 -19 09 43.3 U 12.5 24437632 6274-1432 55 18 31 33.15 -19 13 00.4 U 12.2 24437677 6274-1501 56 18 31 37.80 -19 12 06.8 U 10.6 24437734 6274-1458-1 -19 6891 57 18 31 37.21 -19 10 10.2 U 10.5 24437724 6274-1395-1 -19 6890 58 18 31 33.21 -19 09 05.5 U 12.7 24437679 59 18 31 36.58 -19 08 34.8 U 11.7 24437715 6274-1655-1 60 18 31 32.48 -19 08 20.4 U 14.1 24437668 61 18 31 30.32 -19 08 15.6 U 13.1 24437638 62 18 31 34.80 -19 06 41.2 U 13.7 24437701 63 18 31 31.76 -19 06 05.4 U 11.9 24437657 6274-1650-1 64 18 31 31.2 -19 05 43 M 10.4 6274-1364 3" pair 65 18 31 29.23 -19 05 11.9 U 11.7 24437624 6274-1416-1 66 18 31 28.47 -19 05 09.2 U 12.4 24437611 67 18 31 23.24 -19 04 26.7 U 10.4 24437542 6274-1538-1 -19 6880 68 18 31 27.43 -19 04 10.5 U 12.8 24437595 6274-1274 69 18 31 31.0 -19 03 46 U 10.7 6274-1098 -19 6887 6" pair 70 18 31 33.03 -18 59 46.2 U 9.0 24684231 6274-1131-1 -19 5041 -19 6888 HD 170681 71 18 31 29.33 -18 58 49.8 U 11.6 24684151 6274-1346-1 72 18 31 31.85 -18 58 17.8 U 12.8 24684207 73 18 31 28.89 -18 57 45.1 U 9.7 24684144 6274-1167-1 -19 5040 -19 6885 74 18 31 33.62 -18 57 27.1 U 11.5 24684238 6274-1200 75 18 31 30.44 -18 51 36.5 U 9.8 24684177 6274-1257-1 -18 4989 -18 415 76 18 31 27.54 -18 55 39.6 U 11.0 24684117 6274-1211 77 18 31 44.24 -18 57 43.3 U 12.0 24684432 6274-1242-1 78 18 31 47.30 -18 59 26.1 U 10.3 24684474 6274-1315-1 79 18 31 47.74 -18 59 51.2 U 12.4 24684481 6274-1399 81 18 31 51.24 -19 00 49.6 U 12.7 24437937 6274-1555 82 18 31 48.63 -19 01 21.5 U 13.6 24437888 83 18 31 50.66 -19 01 59.0 U 13.0 24437928 84 18 31 52.99 -19 03 21.4 U 11.7 24437959 6274-1294 85 18 31 40.96 -19 02 10.6 U 12.1 24437777 6274-1129 86 18 31 38.95 -19 03 01.5 M 12.8 87 18 31 49.58 -19 03 17.3 U 13.8 24437905 88 18 31 44.72 -19 03 37.8 U 13.2 24437840 89 18 31 42.84 -19 04 08.7 U 12.2 24437802 90 18 31 40.26 -19 04 43.7 U 12.1 24437764 6274-1513 91 18 31 37.55 -19 05 18.9 T 8.1 6274-1299-1 -19 5042 -19 6892 HD 170719 92 18 31 37.54 -19 06 14.2 U 11.2 24437729 6274-1117 93 18 31 45.01 -19 05 23.5 U 10.4 24437843 6274-1159-1 -19 6901 94 18 31 43.09 -19 05 39.6 U 12.2 24437805 6274-1170-1 95 18 31 41.12 -19 06 09.6 U 12.2 24437778 96 18 31 41.63 -19 06 53.3 U 9.7 24437785 6274-1658-1 -19 6895 97 18 31 43.31 -19 07 02.1 U 8.8 24437809 6274-1479-1 -19 5044 -19 6896 98 18 31 44.56 -19 07 13.6 U 10.2 24437837 6274-1181-1 -19 6897 NSV 24486 99 18 31 44.26 -19 06 34.7 U 9.9 24437834 6274-1379-1 -19 6898 100 18 31 46.33 -19 06 31.4 U 10.1 24437860 6274-1161 -19 6902 101 18 31 48.72 -19 07 00.0 U 10.3 24437889 6274-1427-1 -19 6903 102 18 31 48.9 -19 07 51 T 9.3 24437893 6274-1447 -19 6904 Hen 3-1707 (B8:e), 0".9 cpm pair 103 18 31 53.33 -19 07 30.3 T 6.7 6274-1601-1 -19 5047 -19 6907 U Sgr = HD HD 170764 104 18 31 50.89 -19 05 01.5 U 13.3 24437933 106 18 31 58.76 -19 07 30.0 U 11.2 24438030 6274-1189 NErn of 6" pair (comp red) 107 18 31 39.71 -19 10 04.6 U 12.0 24437754 6274-1229 109 18 31 46.33 -19 09 34.9 U 10.7 24437859 6274-1452-1 -19 6900 110 18 31 43.97 -19 10 20.5 U 9.1 24437823 6274-1444-1 -19 5045 -19 6899 Nrn of 11" pair 110a 18 31 44.09 -19 10 31.3 U 10.1 24437829 6274-1423-1 Srn of 11" pair 111 18 31 50.54 -19 10 10.3 U 9.0 24437924 6274-1331-1 -19 5046 -19 6905 112 18 31 52.38 -19 10 36.9 U 12.3 24437951 6274-1140 113 18 31 52.92 -19 10 24.7 U 12.5 24437958 114 18 31 55.37 -19 10 33.3 U 11.5 24437988 6274-1403 115 18 31 55.74 -19 10 55.9 U 13.2 24437996 116 18 31 52.64 -19 11 48.9 U 12.7 24437953 117 18 31 50.91 -19 12 05.3 M 11.6 6274-1280-1 118 18 31 50.81 -19 12 26.4 U 11.0 24437931 6274-1567 119 18 31 41.84 -19 12 12.6 U 12.3 24437788 6274-1210 122 18 31 42.03 -19 13 04.9 U 11.8 24437792 6274-1345-1 123 18 31 40.94 -19 13 47.3 U 13.8 24437774 124 18 31 38.82 -19 14 30.9 U 12.4 24437745 125 18 31 39.74 -19 15 10.9 U 11.5 24437757 6274-1349-1 126 18 31 41.15 -19 15 17.6 U 9.6 24437779 6274-1251-1 -19 5043 -19 6893 127 18 31 43.20 -19 20 08.0 U 10.8 24437807 6274-1486-1 -19 6894 128 18 31 52.74 -19 18 06.9 U 9.8 24437956 6274-1202-1 -19 6906 129 18 31 53.68 -19 16 57.3 U 11.4 24437966 6274-1610-1 130 18 31 53.75 -19 15 21.6 U 11.1 24437967 6274-1646-1 not double? 132 18 32 01.88 -19 14 12.6 U 13.6 24438068 133 18 32 02.03 -19 12 32.4 U 13.7 24438070 134 18 32 00.70 -19 11 45.4 U 13.7 24438054 144 18 32 04.55 -19 03 49.6 U 13.0 24438107 145 18 32 02.71 -19 05 06.0 M 13.7 147 18 32 07.12 -19 08 06.5 U 12.9 24438145 148 18 32 05.34 -19 08 50.4 U 13.2 24438120 149 18 32 05.20 -19 10 06.1 U 10.4 24438117 6275- 777-1 -19 6910 150 18 32 13.11 -19 07 26.2 U 7.4 24438243 6275- 63-1 -19 5053 -19 6915 HD 170820 151 18 32 17.43 -19 04 06.7 M 11.8 6275-0214 SErn of 4" pair 152 18 32 20.51 -19 04 57.3 U 10.5 24438339 6275- 539-1 153 18 32 27.02 -19 05 55.6 U 9.4 24438442 6275- 479-1 -19 5058 -19 6919 157 18 32 11.41 -19 10 33.0 U 11.9 24438213 6275-0405 158 18 32 09.67 -19 10 51.2 M 13.7 crowded 159 18 32 11.12 -19 11 10.4 U 10.2 24438209 6275- 317-1 -19 5050 -19 6912 160 18 32 13.60 -19 11 43.9 U 13.5 24438251 161 18 32 17.70 -19 10 49.3 U 11.8 24438306 6275-0931 163 18 32 16.44 -19 13 01.8 U 8.8 24438289 6275- 142-1 -19 5055 -19 6917 HD 170835 164 18 32 12.09 -19 14 45.6 U 12.2 24438227 165 18 32 03.88 -19 15 10.5 U 13.6 24438099 166 18 32 05.22 -19 15 31.3 U 11.9 24438118 6275- 647-1 NSV 10972 = MSX6C G013.6081-04.5621 167 18 32 12.30 -19 16 32.6 U 9.0 24438230 6275- 31-1 -19 5052 -19 6914 168 18 32 11.13 -19 20 27.1 U 10.4 24438210 6275- 488-1 -19 5051 -19 6911 172 18 32 21.53 -19 19 28.5 U 12.6 24438357 6275-0924 173 18 32 25.69 -19 18 23.1 U 11.6 24438418 6275-0899 174 18 32 30.85 -19 17 34.1 U 9.0 24438485 6275- 720-1 -19 5060 -19 6923 IRAS 18296-1919 175 18 32 21.12 -19 12 21.3 U 12.5 24438352 182 18 32 16.78 -19 17 56.6 U 14.0 24438297 191 18 32 29.54 -19 02 13.2 U 10.4 24438471 6275- 243-1 -19 6922 192 18 32 37.44 -19 02 42.0 U 10.1 24438567 6275- 201-1 -19 6924 196 18 32 38.03 -19 06 01.8 U 10.9 24438578 6275- 295-1 -19 6925 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- van den Bergh photoelectric sequence in Messier 25 source: 1978AJ.....83.1174V VAN DEN BERGH S. Astron. J., 83, 1174-1178 (1978) UBV observations of the open cluster M25. ID RA (J2000) Dec s UCAC2 V B-V remarks A 18 31 50.42 -19 06 00.9 U 24437920 14.77 2.22 B 18 31 53.69 -19 05 23.7 M 14.88 2.18 C 18 31 53.43 -19 04 17.9 U 24437965 14.98 2.43 SWrn of 2" pair D 18 31 54.66 -19 04 51.2 U 24437979 15.13 0.72 Landolt III-2-14 (15.09,0.80) E 18 31 51.98 -19 04 12.4 U 24437947 15.23 2.01 F 18 31 51.29 -19 07 50.7 U 24437938 15.31 0.88 G 18 31 47.18 -19 08 33.8 U 24437870 15.33 0.73 Landolt I-2-4 (15.19,0.80) H 18 31 53.53 -19 08 25.8 D 15.36 1.01 I 18 31 50.93 -19 08 50.3 U 24437934 15.48 1.46 J 18 31 57.78 -19 07 19.5 U 24438015 15.56 1.17 Landolt III-2-2 (15.38,1.11) K 18 31 49.97 -19 04 31.1 U 24437913 15.70 2.09 L 18 31 54.69 -19 05 22.0 U 24437980 16.32 1.36