Stars in Markarian 18 appear in SIMBAD variously with or without coordinates. Photometry is usually shown, but I include it here for completeness. WEBDA shows coordinates for only the brighter stars. There are also four close pairs involved. Star 1 has a separate entry for its companion that is okay as is. Star 2 has no separate entry for the companion; there doesn't seem to be any information about it, so this is probably also okay. Star 3 & 4 form a slightly wider pair that were measured separately by V&M. There are separate entries for the two in SIMBAD, but also an entry for CD-48 4322. One might assign this to the brighter star 3, but I don't know what the policy is for such cases (it is analogous to the case of an ADS pair: entries for components A and B, then one for the pair together). The similar pair of stars 12 & 13 needs to be made consistent in the same way. The two pairs both have separate Tycho-2 entries, which may decide the matter. The related entries CD-48 4322 and CD-48 4324 both have the comment "Bad CD ??". The two are in fact correct (good CD!), but some decision needs to be made about assigning the names. Mermilliod's WEBDA shows the preferred name of the cluster to be Collinder 205. This is certainly historically correct since Collinder's mongraph antedates Markarian's list by nearly 30 years, but no papers have yet referred to it by this name since Collinder's time. I adopted star 2 as the cluster center in 1995, and don't see any reason to change it now. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Coordinates and identifications for stars in Markarian 18 = Collinder 205 version: 9 Jul 2003 (2MASS position substituted) 25 Nov 2001 (original) source: 1973A&AS....9...97V cluster center = HD 77421: 9 00 31 -48 59.1 (J2000) position sources (column 's'): M 2MASS (II/246) T Tycho-2 (2000A&A...357..367H, I/259) U UCAC1 (2000AJ....120.2131Z, I/268) ID RA (J2000) Dec s GSC Tycho-2 V B-V remarks 1* 9 00 37.12 -48 59 28.4 T 8173-1142 8173-1142-1 9.32 0.58 HD 77434 2* 9 00 31.24 -48 59 04.1 T 8173-0867 8173- 867-1 9.34 0.54 HD 77421 3* 9 00 31.56 -48 58 26.9 T 8173-0682 8173- 682-1 10.07 0.43 CD-48 4322A 4 9 00 32.03 -48 58 19.9 T 8173-1242-1 10.75 0.46 CD-48 4322B 5 9 00 36.39 -48 58 56.3 U 8173-0640 12.52 0.60 6 9 00 36.49 -48 58 38.1 U 8173-0097 8173- 97-1 12.23 0.66 7 9 00 30.50 -48 58 00.1 U 8173-0513 12.86 0.61 8 9 00 31.55 -48 59 14.6 U 8173-0932 8173- 932-1 12.18 0.58 9 9 00 30.47 -48 59 19.1 U 8173-0074 12.37 0.68 10 9 00 29.61 -48 59 46.8 U 8173-0465 12 41 0.62 11 9 00 33.27 -48 58 58.5 M 13.63 0.59 12* 9 00 32.28 -49 00 51.0 T 8173- 531-2 10.67 0.43 CD-48 4324B 13* 9 00 32.82 -49 00 52.3 U 8173-0531 8173- 531-1 10.10 0.31 CD-48 4324A 14 9 00 40.84 -49 01 04.7 U 8173-0532 12.66 0.64 15 9 00 26.44 -48 59 05.5 U 8173-1169 12.65 0.60 16 9 00 40.45 -48 59 28.2 U 13.86 0.65 17 9 00 34.90 -48 59 45.4 U 14.88 0.74 18 9 00 34.67 -49 00 09.7 U 15.77 1.25 Notes 1 position is for brighter component; V&M photometry is for combined light. SIMBAD position for fainter component (CD-48 4325B) is okay. 2 CPD-48 2138A. position is for brighter component; V&M photometry is for combined light. 3 CPD-48 2138B. 12 CPD-48 2140B. 13 CPD-48 2140A.