While getting coordinates for stars in M36 appearing in the 1953 Johnson & Morgan 'original' UBV paper, I noticed that many of the bright stars were not securely identified in SIMBAD. The list below shows coordinates for 200 stars in the first six annular zones measured by Erik Boden in his 1951 monograph on the cluster. I have added a number of stars in outer zones such that the star-list is roughly complete to mag. 14 within a _square_ 20'x20' region. This extends well beyond the main body of the cluster and certainly includes all the bright members. I think this also covers the complete region observed in the proper-motion study by Sanner et al (2000A&A...357..471S). This is less than half the stars measured by Boden, but there must be very few members lurking in the outermost zones. Coordinates I have a paper plot of the six Boden zones plus extra stars based on his x,y coordinates. (No identification chart of the cluster is published!) I used this plot plus a labelled photographic print of the cluster (from a plate taken with the old Lowell 1.1-m reflector) to identify the stars via computer screen-plots of UCAC2. Stars not in UCAC2 were dealt with one-by-one using SkyView cut-outs and then looked up in VizieR. I ran the completed list into VizieR to get Tycho-2 IDs. I have not shown HD/BD names since I think these are complete in SIMBAD in this field. From a small list prepared several years ago, I have added names and spectral types from the large objective-prism survey by Chargeishvili (1988AbaOB..65...18C). His temperature types here seem to be okay, but for the early-B stars the luminosity classes are sometimes much too bright. If there were really so many class I supergiants the cluster would not have been so poorly studied. Morgan showed 50 years ago that the most luminous stars are about B2III. Please note the following minutiae: o The UBV data given by Johnson & Morgan for star 46 is for some other star. I found no obvious (read: too many) alternate candidates. In SIMBAD, the photometry should be replaced with either Boden, Sanner, or my values (see below), near V=14.2. Sanner et al mention this error in their paper. o I noticed four stars with incorrect Boden cross-IDs by Sanner et al. All are fairly close pairs that have IDs switched. I specify the corrections in the notes at the bottom of the table. o Boden 69: this is the faintest star observed by Johnson, but is shown by GCPD, WEBDA, and SIMBAD as having V = 12.43 --- but this should be 12.48. Photometry While collecting information about the cluster some years ago, I compared Boden's photo-visual magnitudes against the Johnson UBV data. Boden of course did his calibration against the North Polar Sequence. I was not surprised to find there was a significant zero-point offset of -0.15 mag, i.e. Boden too bright compared to Johnson V. What _was_ a surprise is that the rms scatter of this offset is only 0.03 mag, which obviously includes the errors in Johnson's photometry. The implication is that the photographic data is of similar internal precision as the photoelectric data. Whoa! I thus show Boden's 'mv' photometry adjusted by +0.15 to match the Johnson zero-point. It is clear that below V ~14 the Boden data become noisy, but this is better than no data for these faint stars. The Johnson UBV data, by the way, is complete in SIMBAD. In October 1991 some CCD frames of the inner parts of the cluster were obtained for me by Bobby Bus using the current Lowell 1.1-m f/8 telescope. The chip was one of the small RCA 320x512 arrays that were common back then. As the cluster passed the _zenith_ Bobby got short- and long-exposure BV frames on two small, overlapping cluster fields plus a set of standards and dome flats. Atmospheric extinction was measured the same night (by me) with the Lowell 53cm photometric telescope. I reduced the CCD data in IRAF via aperture-photometry using the Landolt standards. For stars in common with Johnson, I found simple zero-point offsets of 0.03 to 0.04 in both V and B-V. The internal scatter wrt Johnson was commendably small, between 0.010 and 0.015 mag. Now normally one might say that since the calibration was against Landolt stars, the CCD results "must" be correct. However, the Johnson photometry is in that 'original' UBV paper itself, and one would have a hard time arguing with a referee that single-night CCD data was better. (At least if _I_ was the referee!) If I had consistent data on, say, four or five nights, then I'd be prepared to claim Johnson got it wrong, since some of his other cluster zero-points are a bit off. Well, I applied mean offsets to adjust the CCD data to Johnson, and the results are shown in the table under 'Skiff V, B-V'. This is single-night data, but seems to be reliable at < 0.02 in both V and B-V relative to the 1953 Johnson zero-points. I show data only for Boden stars --- there are more fainter stars in the reduced lists. Other new data: I spent a couple of mornings in October 1996 measuring several bright and faint stars in the outer field of the cluster using the Lowell 53cm telescope and its Stromgren y and b filters. The aim was to get some fainter stars Johnson had not measured to help calibrate V-band plates taken for proper motion with the Yerkes 40-inch refractor (about which more to follow). Getting down past V=12 with the 53cm telescope and Stromgren filters was too time-consuming, so I abandoned this effort. The V/b-y results are shown in the notes at the bottom of the table, and are from two nights of data for the bright stars, but only n=1 (as indicated) for the faint ones. The latter have likely errors in the +/-0.05 mag range, but only ~0.01 for the brighter stars. Comparison with Boden is again good. The mean V offset relative to the Johnson zero-point is -0.018 +/- 0.008 (rms) for the five brighter stars measured on two nights. These data should be systematically very close to standard V as defined by the Landolt equatorial standards, so this is perhaps additional evidence that the 1953 Johnson zero-point is soft. The 53cm telescope photometric calibration stars included primary and secondary Stromgren standards, among the latter especially HD 21856. This is a Johnson 'prime list' star (so V is secure), and is a B1V star with reddening nearly identical to M36 itself. The recent work by Sanner et al of the cluster proper motion also includes one-night CCD data. Their claimed errors are fairly soft (sigma = 0.02 in V, and 0.06 in B-V), and the B-V color term in their transformation is large (0.19), perhaps explaining the large B-V errors. For stars in common with Boden and my data, the results seem to be consistent within the uncertainties just quoted. With two iffy single-night datasets, and only the 'ancient' UBV data by Johnson, the last word on photometry in the cluster has not yet been spoken. Finally, as regards photometry of the cluster, I note that Anne Marie Jakobsen apparently did a comprehensive four-color Stromgren survey of the cluster with Dave Crawford at Kitt Peak in the mid-1980s. This data seems never to have been published. Perhaps in her Copenhagen dissertation? Proper Motions After building the list of coordinates mainly from UCAC2, I noticed that comparison of the proper motions between UCAC2 and Sanner et al showed a systematic difference. Both sets of motions are nominally tied to the Hipparcos-based reference frame. Sanner et al used the ACT catalogue, but this should have satisfactorily small global errors wrt to the ICRF. Although motions are less than 10 mas/year, I note that Sanner et al find the cluster motion to be twice as large as what's given by UCAC2 in Declination, and in RA their motion is both larger and of opposite sign than UCAC2 (or Tycho-2). This is not a cos-Dec/non-cos-Dec error! Sanner et al say that there was little difference between the bulk motion of the cluster and of mean motion for the field (mainly south but slightly eastward). I would expect the cluster to have very small motion (as shown by UCAC2), and that the field stars, invariably much closer, would show general flow toward the solar ant-apex. I don't know a lot about this sort of thing, so I may be missing something, but one dataset or the other seems to have problems. Perhaps some local zonal error in the ACT is responsible, or a simlar 'funny' in UCAC2, which would be disconcerting. In October 1991 I helped Kyle Cudworth do a fairly thorough proper-motion study of this cluster using Yerkes 40-inch refractor plates spanning a 70-year baseline. This is similar in time-span to the Bonn refractor plates used by Sanner et al, but with 4x larger image-scale. The new plates were taken by Kyle for this project. I scanned the plates on the PDS machine in Madison, and then pretty much merely watched Kyle do the complex, iterative reductions at Yerkes, while learning a lot about astrometry-of-precision at large image scales (10.-something arcsec/mm). Largely from sloth on my part, this work has not been completed/published, but given the 'funnies' with the Sanner et al results, perhaps it is time to dust off this material and get it out. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Coordinates and identifications for stars in NGC 1960 = Messier 36 version: 2016 Apr 16, material added 2005 Mar 6 source: 1951UppAn...3d...1B BODEN E. Uppsala Astron. Obs. Ann., 3, part no 4, 1-29 (1951) Photographic, photovisual, and red magnitudes in the galactic cluster M 36. Dictionary: (Nos 1-576). cluster center (star 16): 5 36 16 +34 08.6 (J2000) position sources (column 's'): M 2MASS (II/246) T Tycho-2 (2000A&A...357..367H, I/259) U UCAC2 (2004AJ....127.3043Z, I/289) --- stars in Boden zones 1 to 6 shown here Boden Johnson Skiff J&M 1953 Abastumani spec Boden RA (J2000) Dec s UCAC2 Tycho-2 V V B-V U-B V B-V NGC 1960 1 5 36 17.85 +34 09 14.7 U 43762556 14.00 13.996 0.512 NGC 1960 2 5 36 20.04 +34 09 14.5 U 43762566 14.08 14.236 0.554 NGC 1960 3 5 36 21.39 +34 09 41.0 U 43762579 2412-0735-1 10.71 10.72 0.097 -0.25 10.744 0.092 NGC 1960 4 5 36 23.62 +34 09 15.0 M 14.06 14.078 0.652 NGC 1960 5 5 36 24.44 +34 08 28.2 U 43762598 12.86 12.839 0.207 NGC 1960 6 5 36 19.13 +34 07 59.6 U 43762560 13.96 13.988 0.514 NGC 1960 7 5 36 20.99 +34 08 09.0 U 43762574 12.17 12.171 0.317 NGC 1960 8 5 36 21.94 +34 08 08.2 T 2412-1700-1 9.30 9.36 0.020 -0.58 B2V NGC 1960 9 5 36 22.66 +34 08 01.8 T 2412-1701-1 9.07 9.13 -0.002 -0.66 B2V AAO +34 249 B2II NGC 1960 10 5 36 21.52 +34 07 44.9 M 14.29 14.194 0.481 NGC 1960 11 5 36 22.14 +34 07 13.8 U 43762583 2412-1382-1 11.22 11.24 0.104 -0.30 11.236 0.104 NGC 1960 12 5 36 21.25 +34 07 06.4 U 43762578 12.96 12.940 0.244 NGC 1960 13 5 36 15.29 +34 07 12.4 U 43762538 2412-1375-1 10.77 10.80 0.126 -0.28 10.812 0.126 B8:nn NGC 1960 14 5 36 14.09 +34 07 08.2 U 43762530 2412-1496-1 10.69 10.68 0.092 -0.38 10.690 0.098 B8:III/IV AAO +34 244 B3III NGC 1960 15 5 36 13.78 +34 07 16.1 M 13.98 NGC 1960 16* 5 36 15.80 +34 08 36.6 U 43762541 2412-1639-1 8.88 8.86 -0.001 -0.66 8.848 B2V AAO +34 245 B2I NGC 1960 17 5 36 14.46 +34 08 23.9 U 43762533 12.44 12.437 0.233 NGC 1960 18* 5 36 12.57 +34 08 58.5 U 43762525 2412-0625-1 10.75 10.78 0.077 -0.37 10.788 0.082 AAO +34 243 B2III NGC 1960 19 5 36 13.55 +34 09 25.0 U 43762528 13.62 13.569 0.515 NGC 1960 20 5 36 18.57 +34 10 46.0 U 43762559 12.29 12.341 0.265 NGC 1960 21 5 36 21.06 +34 10 16.7 U 43762575 2412-0983-1 9.70 9.76 0.012 -0.60 B2.5V AAO +34 247 B2III NGC 1960 22 5 36 21.54 +34 09 51.1 U 43762580 12.23 12.230 0.139 NGC 1960 23 5 36 23.05 +34 10 32.7 U 43762590 2412-1645-1 8.91 8.96 0.008 -0.68 B3V AAO +34 250 B2I NGC 1960 24 5 36 19.36 +34 11 16.9 U 43762562 14.54 14.546 0.583 NGC 1960 25 5 36 25.01 +34 09 17.4 U 43762601 14.77 14.732 0.625 NGC 1960 26 5 36 28.63 +34 09 49.3 M 14.47 14.448 0.586 NGC 1960 27* 5 36 28.03 +34 08 30.6 U 43762617 2412-1659-1 9.56 9.58 0.020 -0.58 9.559 B2?nn AAO +34 251 B0V NGC 1960 28 5 36 29.46 +34 08 07.8 U 43762626 12.81 12.810 0.190 NGC 1960 29* 5 36 27.51 +34 07 47.0 M 14.85 NGC 1960 30 5 36 28.05 +34 07 49.0 U 43762618 2412-1549-1 12.06 12.03 0.142 -0.14 12.048 0.127 NGC 1960 31 5 36 29.11 +34 07 42.1 U 43762623 14.44 14.143 0.531 NGC 1960 32 5 36 26.45 +34 07 39.3 U 43762610 14.08 14.063 0.908 NGC 1960 33 5 36 28.36 +34 07 21.5 U 43762620 11.87 11.87 0.124 -0.12 11.861 0.113 B9:V: NGC 1960 34 5 36 26.50 +34 07 18.3 M 14.04 13.976 0.605 NGC 1960 35 5 36 26.93 +34 06 52.8 M 14.77 14.624 0.624 NGC 1960 36 5 36 26.58 +34 06 21.4 U 43762611 12.76 12.751 0.328 NGC 1960 37 5 36 25.11 +34 06 10.1 U 43762603 13.98 14.000 0.500 NGC 1960 38 5 36 23.84 +34 05 57.2 U 43762597 2412-1284-1 9.89 9.92 0.054 -0.49 NGC 1960 39 5 36 22.53 +34 06 08.2 M 13.36 13.347 0.314 NGC 1960 40 5 36 20.75 +34 06 50.2 U 43762572 12.30 12.343 0.271 NGC 1960 41* 5 36 20.03 +34 06 11.4 U 43762565 12.37 12.38 0.189 0.04 12.392 0.140 NGC 1960 42 5 36 13.25 +34 05 57.9 U 43762527 13.64 13.540 0.527 NGC 1960 43 5 36 12.32 +34 05 36.2 U 43762524 13.61 13.554 0.404 NGC 1960 44 5 36 11.54 +34 07 06.4 U 43762522 2412-1055-1 11.38 11.38 0.090 -0.29 11.373 0.095 B8:III/IV AAO +34 242 B2V NGC 1960 45* 5 36 06.79 +34 06 46.0 M 13.21 13.201 0.341 NGC 1960 46* 5 36 09.07 +34 07 17.0 U 43762506 14.19 12.32 0.282 0.15 14.246 0.647 NGC 1960 47 5 36 07.20 +34 08 03.3 U 43762495 2412-0085-1 10.45 10.44 0.120 -0.25 10.433 0.118 B8? NGC 1960 48 5 36 07.90 +34 08 50.3 U 43762500 2412-0881-1 9.51 9.52 0.061 -0.46 B3V AAO +34 239 B2I NGC 1960 49 5 36 09.46 +34 08 51.1 M 14.22 14.111 0.527 NGC 1960 50 5 36 07.75 +34 09 25.0 U 43762499 2412-1091-1 11.58 11.61 0.202 -0.12 11.605 0.202 B9? NGC 1960 51* 5 36 11.78 +34 09 30.1 M 14.44 NGC 1960 52 5 36 11.44 +34 09 33.7 M 13.40 NGC 1960 53 5 36 08.03 +34 09 52.6 M 13.49 13.489 0.395 NGC 1960 54 5 36 08.36 +34 10 12.1 M 13.40 13.329 0.303 NGC 1960 55 5 36 19.49 +34 12 14.8 U 43762563 2412-0321-1 11.64 11.62 0.102 -0.30 NGC 1960 56 5 36 20.36 +34 12 13.4 U 43762569 2412-0967-1 12.44 12.42 0.44 0.24 NGC 1960 57 5 36 20.89 +34 12 43.1 U 43762573 2412-1344-1 11.75 11.78 0.123 -0.12 NGC 1960 58 5 36 23.21 +34 12 39.4 M 13.92 NGC 1960 59 5 36 25.66 +34 11 31.1 U 43762606 13.12 13.134 0.283 NGC 1960 60 5 36 28.29 +34 12 21.2 U 43762619 14.17 NGC 1960 61 5 36 32.00 +34 10 47.3 U 43762641 2412-1516-1 9.09 9.14 0.010 -0.66 B2V: AAO +34 252 B2I NGC 1960 62 5 36 36.69 +34 10 24.9 T 43762667 2412-1302-2 11.93 NGC 1960 63 5 36 33.38 +34 10 12.9 U 43762649 14.29 NGC 1960 64 5 36 33.78 +34 08 04.4 M 13.84 NGC 1960 65* 5 36 40.87 +34 07 47.2 U 43762688 12.71 12.668 NGC 1960 66 5 36 39.74 +34 06 44.8 U 43762681 13.54 NGC 1960 67 5 36 33.94 +34 07 17.6 U 43762654 12.41 NGC 1960 68 5 36 33.50 +34 06 31.6 U 43762651 12.89 NGC 1960 69* 5 36 30.82 +34 06 06.4 U 43762636 12.49 12.48 0.20 -0.38 NGC 1960 70 5 36 33.34 +34 06 05.4 U 43762648 14.31 NGC 1960 71* 5 36 29.31 +34 04 17.5 U 43762625 12.19 12.16 0.158 -0.05 12.144 NGC 1960 72 5 36 25.38 +34 04 46.9 U 43762605 14.52 NGC 1960 73 5 36 24.03 +34 04 43.3 M 14.57 NGC 1960 74 5 36 22.05 +34 04 26.9 U 43762582 14.62 NGC 1960 75 5 36 22.40 +34 03 54.4 U 43762586 14.90 NGC 1960 76 5 36 20.26 +34 04 32.9 U 43762567 13.30 NGC 1960 77* 5 36 16.63 +34 05 00.8 U 43762545 2412-0241-1 12.15 12.11 0.16 0.00 12.119 NGC 1960 78 5 36 05.31 +34 06 01.2 U 43762486 13.64 13.560 0.406 NGC 1960 79 5 36 02.66 +34 06 06.2 U 43762472 11.96 11.93 0.12 -0.12 11.893 0.102 NGC 1960 80 5 36 01.72 +34 06 21.8 U 43762465 13.14 13.050 0.467 NGC 1960 81 5 36 02.39 +34 06 50.9 U 43762470 2412-1235-1 10.01 10.01 0.024 -0.57 B2III AAO +34 237 B9p NGC 1960 82* 5 36 01.06 +34 07 43.4 U 43762461 14.21 14.099 NGC 1960 83 5 35 58.40 +34 08 11.7 U 43762445 14.75 NGC 1960 84* 5 36 02.58 +34 09 13.3 M 13.46 13.315 0.396 NGC 1960 85 5 36 01.96 +34 09 17.6 U 43762466 11.34 11.30 0.145 -0.27 11.305 0.163 NGC 1960 86 5 36 03.28 +34 10 07.8 U 43762475 2412-1429-1 10.67 10.65 0.060 -0.24 10.638 0.065 B8?III/IV NGC 1960 87 5 35 59.27 +34 10 27.4 U 43762452 2412-0369-1 10.66 10.65 0.068 -0.40 B6:V AAO +34 238 A2III NGC 1960 88 5 36 03.78 +34 10 54.0 M 13.22 13.091 1.286 NGC 1960 89 5 36 03.08 +34 11 13.7 U 43762473 13.20 13.140 0.293 NGC 1960 90 5 36 10.89 +34 11 21.6 U 43762516 13.45 13.366 0.329 NGC 1960 91 5 36 09.77 +34 11 35.9 U 43762510 2412-0901-1 10.35 10.37 0.038 -0.47 NGC 1960 92 5 36 05.93 +34 12 03.2 U 43762491 2412-0675-1 10.97 10.96 0.048 -0.44 10.945 0.063 NGC 1960 93 5 36 05.51 +34 12 18.5 U 43762488 13.81 NGC 1960 94 5 36 13.66 +34 12 43.1 U 43762529 13.44 NGC 1960 95 5 36 17.75 +34 11 58.8 U 43762554 14.46 14.410 0.589 NGC 1960 96* 5 36 23.19 +34 14 25.8 U 43762591 13.80 NGC 1960 97 5 36 28.79 +34 14 07.1 U 43762621 14.90 NGC 1960 98 5 36 32.11 +34 13 41.1 U 43762642 12.82 NGC 1960 99 5 36 37.18 +34 12 39.2 U 43762673 14.30 NGC 1960 100 5 36 40.34 +34 12 22.6 U 43762686 13.93 NGC 1960 101* 5 36 42.30 +34 12 05.9 U 43762698 2412-0277-1 9.23 9.23 0.050 -0.69 B2Ve AAO +34 256 B2e NGC 1960 102 5 36 41.27 +34 09 29.8 U 43762693 14.04 NGC 1960 103 5 36 44.27 +34 07 10.3 U 43762710 14.24 NGC 1960 104 5 36 39.45 +34 06 12.3 U 43762680 14.06 NGC 1960 105 5 36 41.97 +34 06 13.8 U 43762697 14.56 NGC 1960 106 5 36 45.22 +34 05 47.4 U 43762716 12.64 NGC 1960 107 5 36 33.52 +34 04 47.1 U 43762652 13.08 NGC 1960 108 5 36 36.44 +34 04 17.1 U 43762665 12.24 NGC 1960 109 5 36 34.77 +34 03 55.5 U 43762660 2412-1515-1 10.71 10.70 0.080 -0.41 AAO +34 254 B2I NGC 1960 110 5 36 21.18 +34 03 17.4 U 43762576 2412-1705-1 12.01 11.98 0.204 -0.07 NGC 1960 111 5 36 19.51 +34 02 59.7 M 14.04 NGC 1960 112* 5 36 15.61 +34 03 25.2 U 43762539 12.34 12.30 0.212 0.04 12.251 NGC 1960 113 5 36 03.24 +34 03 37.4 U 43762474 2412-0843-1 10.55 10.54 0.106 0.03 AAO +34 236 B3V NGC 1960 114 5 36 02.22 +34 04 40.5 U 43762469 11.86 11.82 0.30 -0.06 NGC 1960 115 5 35 59.24 +34 03 56.8 U 43762451 13.17 NGC 1960 116 5 35 57.74 +34 04 59.9 U 43762442 13.59 NGC 1960 117 5 35 50.84 +34 06 03.5 U 43762410 14.10 NGC 1960 118 5 35 52.08 +34 07 38.7 U 43762418 13.17 NGC 1960 119 5 35 53.58 +34 08 00.8 U 43762427 14.14 NGC 1960 120 5 35 52.38 +34 08 57.5 U 43762421 13.61 NGC 1960 121 5 35 51.46 +34 09 27.5 U 43762414 14.97 NGC 1960 122 5 35 55.77 +34 10 07.4 U 43762436 14.68 NGC 1960 123 5 35 51.66 +34 10 32.4 U 43762416 2412-1292-1 11.59 11.53 0.106 -0.25 AAO +34 235 B8V NGC 1960 124 5 36 03.54 +34 13 19.8 M 13.93 NGC 1960 125 5 36 05.37 +34 13 53.1 U 43762487 13.86 NGC 1960 126 5 36 08.25 +34 14 21.0 U 43762502 2412-1583-1 11.03 11.00 1.005 0.66 AAO +34 240 B2V (ID error?) NGC 1960 127 5 36 15.77 +34 14 18.0 U 43762540 2412-1425-1 11.36 11.34 0.418 -0.40 AAO +34 246 B3V NGC 1960 128 5 36 34.09 +34 14 50.4 U 43762655 13.97 NGC 1960 129 5 36 34.37 +34 13 51.5 U 43762657 13.81 NGC 1960 130 5 36 36.76 +34 14 29.3 U 43762668 13.87 NGC 1960 131 5 36 38.37 +34 14 52.4 U 43762676 13.49 NGC 1960 132 5 36 45.31 +34 13 04.4 U 43762717 14.66 NGC 1960 133 5 36 52.61 +34 08 37.1 U 43762743 14.58 NGC 1960 134* 5 36 50.77 +34 08 13.2 U 43762736 2412-0293-1 10.25 AAO +34 258 B2II NGC 1960 135 5 36 49.50 +34 06 04.6 U 43762732 13.02 NGC 1960 136 5 36 49.76 +34 05 41.8 U 43762733 12.99 NGC 1960 137 5 36 48.38 +34 05 14.0 U 43762730 14.39 NGC 1960 138 5 36 39.26 +34 03 49.8 U 43762679 2412-1383-1 9.00 9.04 0.022 -0.60 B3:V: AAO +34 255 B2II NGC 1960 139 5 36 38.72 +34 03 36.9 U 43762677 11.86 NGC 1960 140 5 36 36.80 +34 03 08.4 U 43762669 13.67 NGC 1960 141 5 36 25.05 +34 00 39.9 U 43762602 14.72 NGC 1960 142 5 36 11.24 +34 02 10.2 U 43762520 14.05 NGC 1960 143 5 36 03.68 +34 02 28.9 U 43762480 14.63 NGC 1960 144 5 35 59.59 +34 01 55.8 U 43762455 2412-1582-1 12.55 NGC 1960 145* 5 35 52.95 +34 02 34.1 U 43762425 2412-1356-1 12.11 12.07 0.36 0.10 NGC 1960 146 5 35 52.08 +34 04 33.6 U 43762417 12.46 NGC 1960 147 5 35 40.91 +34 07 17.6 U 43762366 14.52 NGC 1960 148 5 35 45.39 +34 07 34.1 U 43762387 2412-0775-1 10.89 NGC 1960 149 5 35 44.62 +34 07 59.6 U 43762383 14.33 NGC 1960 150 5 35 46.54 +34 09 57.4 U 43762396 12.88 NGC 1960 151 5 35 44.19 +34 10 28.6 U 43762382 14.89 NGC 1960 152 5 35 42.30 +34 10 54.7 U 43762374 2412-0087-1 11.26 11.26 0.022 -0.39 AAO +34 233 B5p NGC 1960 153 5 35 46.81 +34 11 49.2 M 13.88 NGC 1960 154 5 35 49.11 +34 11 56.0 U 43762405 12.53 NGC 1960 155 5 35 47.54 +34 12 14.8 U 43762400 13.27 NGC 1960 156 5 35 58.60 +34 13 27.4 U 43762448 14.33 NGC 1960 157 5 36 02.10 +34 14 12.0 U 43762468 13.70 NGC 1960 158 5 36 03.58 +34 15 36.5 U 43762477 13.03 NGC 1960 159 5 36 10.02 +34 15 36.6 U 43762512 13.66 NGC 1960 160 5 36 17.23 +34 15 12.8 M 13.23 NGC 1960 161 5 36 17.68 +34 15 41.6 U 43762552 14.50 NGC 1960 162 5 36 15.28 +34 15 55.7 U 43762537 14.77 NGC 1960 163 5 36 28.17 +34 17 32.3 M 13.60 NGC 1960 164 5 36 31.60 +34 16 26.3 U 43762639 14.64 NGC 1960 165 5 36 44.90 +34 14 53.8 U 43762715 13.86 NGC 1960 166 5 36 47.05 +34 14 39.5 M 14.94 NGC 1960 167 5 36 55.03 +34 11 52.3 U 43762757 11.79 NGC 1960 168 5 36 56.87 +34 11 42.2 U 43762764 13.37 NGC 1960 169 5 36 58.69 +34 06 52.8 U 43762774 14.23 NGC 1960 170 5 36 55.07 +34 05 51.0 U 43762758 2412-1041-1 10.56 AAO +34 260 B8V NGC 1960 171 5 36 53.67 +34 04 31.8 U 43762752 11.34 NGC 1960 172 5 36 52.53 +34 04 14.0 U 43762742 14.64 NGC 1960 173 5 36 54.04 +34 03 26.3 U 43762753 12.53 NGC 1960 174 5 36 26.94 +33 59 46.5 U 43589789 13.98 NGC 1960 175 5 36 23.50 +34 00 09.8 U 43762594 2412-0653-1 11.34 NGC 1960 176 5 36 22.91 +33 59 20.2 M 13.45 NGC 1960 177 5 36 17.74 +33 59 44.2 U 43589745 13.53 NGC 1960 178 5 36 16.90 +34 00 16.5 U 43762547 12.67 NGC 1960 179 5 36 10.59 +33 59 00.2 U 43589715 13.94 NGC 1960 180 5 36 04.93 +33 59 59.7 U 43589682 2412-1123-1 11.14 NGC 1960 181 5 36 00.31 +34 00 56.0 U 43762457 14.12 NGC 1960 182 5 35 53.75 +34 01 49.6 U 43762428 12.93 NGC 1960 183 5 35 49.34 +34 02 49.2 U 43762406 13.36 NGC 1960 184* 5 35 46.43 +34 03 17.4 U 43762395 2412-0053-1 10.01 9.98 0.970 0.60 9.967 AAO +34 234 G8III NGC 1960 185 5 35 42.75 +34 02 56.4 U 43762377 13.55 NGC 1960 186 5 35 42.25 +34 04 05.4 U 43762373 13.60 NGC 1960 187 5 35 40.32 +34 06 07.7 U 43762363 12.70 NGC 1960 188 5 35 34.01 +34 08 19.6 M 13.81 NGC 1960 189 5 35 33.39 +34 08 22.3 U 43762336 12.63 NGC 1960 190 5 35 37.74 +34 08 43.4 U 43762353 14.33 NGC 1960 191 5 35 36.16 +34 09 04.3 U 43762345 14.31 NGC 1960 192 5 35 32.83 +34 09 13.4 M 13.85 NGC 1960 193 5 35 41.71 +34 12 48.5 U 43762372 13.93 NGC 1960 194 5 35 48.86 +34 14 30.8 U 43762404 2412-0159-1 12.41 NGC 1960 195 5 35 59.47 +34 16 16.3 U 43762454 12.64 NGC 1960 196 5 36 01.30 +34 16 21.8 U 43762463 2412-1179-1 9.97 9.91 1.262 1.04 NGC 1960 197 5 36 09.40 +34 16 55.3 U 43762508 2412-1319-1 9.62 9.62 0.045 -0.48 AAO +34 241 B2V NGC 1960 198 5 36 11.21 +34 17 00.2 M 13.97 NGC 1960 199 5 36 14.66 +34 16 19.7 U 43762535 2412-1225-1 12.15 NGC 1960 200 5 36 15.82 +34 17 47.4 U 43762542 13.11 NGC 1960 202 5 36 36.61 +34 17 49.2 U 43762666 14.79 NGC 1960 203 5 37 02.62 +34 13 49.2 U 43762797 2412-1358-1 10.36 AAO +34 262 F0V NGC 1960 204 5 37 06.10 +34 12 33.6 U 43762806 12.57 NGC 1960 205 5 37 05.65 +34 11 30.6 U 43762804 12.18 NGC 1960 206 5 37 03.76 +34 11 02.8 M 13.81 NGC 1960 207 5 37 05.67 +34 09 36.9 U 43762805 13.60 NGC 1960 208 5 37 05.08 +34 06 38.2 M 14.09 NGC 1960 209 5 37 06.96 +34 06 05.9 U 43762809 13.13 NGC 1960 210 5 37 09.40 +34 05 43.9 U 43762820 2412-0613-1 10.44 NGC 1960 211 5 37 06.99 +34 05 30.1 U 43762810 14.91 NGC 1960 212 5 37 04.81 +34 03 43.2 U 43762802 15.24 NGC 1960 213 5 37 02.20 +34 03 24.0 U 43762794 14.49 NGC 1960 214 5 36 59.13 +34 02 44.8 U 43762776 13.66 NGC 1960 215 5 36 36.69 +33 59 21.5 U 43589835 14.54 NGC 1960 218 5 35 45.44 +34 00 23.1 U 43762389 12.14 NGC 1960 220 5 35 41.01 +34 01 50.3 U 43762367 13.53 NGC 1960 221 5 35 37.05 +34 01 33.8 U 43762351 14.75 NGC 1960 222 5 35 33.56 +34 02 22.4 U 43762337 14.33 NGC 1960 223 5 35 34.78 +34 04 59.3 U 43762340 13.67 NGC 1960 224 5 35 31.54 +34 06 09.0 U 43762329 14.37 NGC 1960 226 5 35 31.70 +34 07 40.8 U 43762332 14.92 NGC 1960 228 5 35 31.37 +34 08 22.0 U 43762326 14.26 NGC 1960 230 5 35 32.43 +34 10 19.2 U 43762334 2412-1520-1 11.89 AAO +34 231 B8V NGC 1960 231 5 35 30.23 +34 10 58.8 U 43762321 12.37 AAO +34 230 B8IV NGC 1960 233 5 35 41.64 +34 14 49.0 U 43762370 13.33 NGC 1960 234 5 35 54.52 +34 16 43.8 U 43762432 13.79 NGC 1960 235 5 35 57.00 +34 18 08.8 U 43762438 14.98 NGC 1960 236 5 36 06.38 +34 18 14.0 U 43762493 14.24 NGC 1960 237 5 36 08.94 +34 18 59.6 U 43762505 14.49 NGC 1960 238 5 36 11.67 +34 18 41.6 U 43762523 13.24 NGC 1960 239 5 36 17.16 +34 18 43.0 U 43762549 12.97 NGC 1960 247 5 36 57.87 +34 00 42.3 U 43762769 12.79 NGC 1960 252* 5 35 44.08 +33 59 44.3 U 43589581 2412-0249-1 9.10 9.12 0.00 -0.36 9.090 NGC 1960 253 5 35 39.53 +33 59 38.9 U 43589562 14.39 NGC 1960 270 5 37 06.34 +33 59 24.2 U 43589969 12.35 Notes 16 V = 8.848, b-y = 0.074 (n=2) 18 V = 10.767, b-y = 0.114 (n=2) 27 V = 9.559, b-y = 0.105 (n=2) 29 SAB 40 data is for Boden 30 41 Johnson B-V poor? 45 V = 13.192, b-y = 0.250 (n=1) 46 Johnson UBV data are for another star 51 SAB 76 data is for Boden 52 65 V = 12.668, b-y = 0.226 (n=1). 69 GCPD/SIMBAD V error: V = 12.48, not 12.43 71 V = 12.144, b-y = 0.137 (n=1) 77 V = 12.119, b-y = 0.152 (n=1) 82 V = 14.099, b-y = 0.513 (n=1) 84 SAB 28 data is for Boden 85 96 red star: 2MASS J-K=1.2 101 cluster standard(!) V431 Aur: V = 9.176, b-y = 0.109, V = 9.228, b-y = 0.100 (BSkiff, two nights); Boden V = 8.94, HIP mean V = 9.03, Tyc2 V = 9.06. TASS MkIV V=9.14 and W-S index = 8.3 from 46 nights. 112 V = 12.251, b-y = 0.222 (n=1) 134 SAB 13 V mag is wrong 145 Tyc2 coords poor 184 cluster standard; V = 9.967, b-y = 0.629 (n=2) 252 V = 9.090, b-y = 0.057 (n=2)