There are minor mix-ups in SIMBAD for stars in the cluster NGC 2335 observed by Claria and by Seggewiss. All the stars are present in SIMBAD but mostly with approximate coordinates. Three stars observed by Seggewiss (and not by Claria) are present but without coordinates. Star NGC 2335 59 is not labelled on Claria's chart, and appears to be lost for now. There is a SIMBAD entry for it without coordinates; I'm not sure what should done here---perhaps leave it with a comment added? The WEBDA semi-accurate position for star 61 (Seggewiss 6) appears to be in error. Two BD names have been overlooked by SIMBAD and/or WEBDA (stars 8 and 10). The Lynga/SIMBAD/WEBDA position for the cluster center is wrong. Adopting star 8 as the center is more nearly correct. It seems to me that Claria's U-B colors for red giants are too blue for most of the stars. Usually you expect that the U-B value will be larger than B-V for B-V > 1.2. U-B stays smaller than B-V for K/M dwarfs. The implication is that these red stars are dwarfs, whereas the proper-motion information and 2MASS J-K colors imply they are all giants (as expected). ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Coordinates and identifications for stars in NGC 2335 version: 4 Dec 2003: V mags added 30 Nov 2001 sources: 1973A&AS....9..251C 1971VeBon..83...19S (stars 61-63) cluster center = BD-09 1849 (star 8): 7 06 49 -10 01.7 (J2000) position sources (column 's'): M 2MASS (B/2mass/out) T Tycho-2 (2000A&A...357..367H, I/259) Name RA (J2000) Dec s GSC Tycho-2 V remarks 1 7 07 21.69 -09 59 06.5 T 5385-2101 5385-2101-1 7.0 HD 54141 2 7 06 28.21 -10 13 09.0 T 5385-0206 5385- 206-1 7.9 HD 53907 3 7 06 12.39 -10 09 59.2 T 5385-1690 5385-1690-1 8.1 HD 53824 4* 7 06 52.00 -10 02 54.4 T 5385-0632 5385- 632-1 9.5 BD-09 1851 5 7 06 42.94 -10 09 22.7 T 5385-0985 5385- 985-1 10.0 BD-09 1848 6 7 06 21.54 -10 10 36.2 T 5385-0421 5385- 421-1 10.0 BD-09 1845 7 7 06 34.87 -09 54 03.9 T 5385-0899 5385- 899-1 10.1 BD-09 1847 8 7 06 49.39 -10 01 42.3 T 5385-1230 5385-1230-1 10.6 BD-09 1849 9* 7 06 27.57 -10 09 48.9 T 5385-0708 5385- 708-1 10.6 10 7 06 13.44 -09 54 13.2 T 5385-0480 5385- 480-1 10.7 BD-09 1843 11 7 06 11.42 -09 56 22.7 M 5385-0469 10.9 12 7 06 57.24 -10 02 55.0 T 5385-0229 5385- 229-1 11.0 13 7 06 05.05 -10 03 46.6 T 5385-1443 5385-1443-1 11.1 14* 7 06 24.04 -10 04 43.0 T 5385-1822 5385-1822-1 11.3 15 7 06 23.17 -09 53 12.4 T 5385-1018 5385-1018-1 11.4 16 7 07 14.25 -10 03 14.7 T 5385-0795 5385- 795-1 11.5 17 7 06 48.78 -09 58 24.6 T 5385-1272 5385-1272-1 11.5 18 7 06 31.89 -10 07 39.6 T 5385-1651 5385-1651-1 11.6 19 7 06 18.05 -10 04 08.1 T 5385-0885 5385- 885-1 11.6 20 7 06 40.83 -10 00 42.8 T 5385-0915 5385- 915-1 11.6 21 7 06 53.80 -10 01 49.5 T 5385-1188 5385-1188-1 11.7 22 7 06 47.40 -09 58 29.4 M 5385-0515 11.7 23 7 06 54.09 -10 06 23.6 M 5385-0908 11.9 NSV 17344 24* 7 06 49.03 -10 06 40.8 M 5385-1103 11.9 25 7 06 41.09 -10 02 57.7 M 5385-1487 12.0 NSV 17341 26 7 07 12.14 -10 04 07.1 M 5385-1035 12.0 27 7 07 13.70 -09 56 22.9 M 5385-1500 12.0 28 7 06 35.72 -10 00 05.9 M 5385-0150 12.1 29 7 06 24.08 -09 56 36.6 M 5385-1243 12.1 30 7 06 49.50 -10 02 45.6 M 5385-0364 12.2 31 7 06 41.61 -10 02 27.6 T 5385-0752 5385- 752-1 12.2 32 7 06 42.17 -10 06 06.9 M 5385-0369 12.3 33 7 06 46.01 -10 03 14.3 M 5385-0671 12.3 34 7 06 44.10 -10 03 47.8 M 5385-1504 12.3 NSV 17342 35 7 06 26.86 -09 55 25.8 M 5385-0051 12.4 NSV 17337 36 7 07 06.60 -09 56 36.2 M 5385-0430 12.4 37 7 06 45.14 -10 03 03.7 M 5385-0245 12.4 38 7 06 38.05 -09 59 03.5 T 5385-0946 5385- 946-1 12.5 39 7 06 58.34 -10 05 31.4 M 5385-1484 12.5 40 7 07 15.37 -09 59 30.1 M 5385-1721 12.5 41 7 06 24.10 -10 04 23.5 M 5385-0813 12.7 42 7 06 46.43 -09 57 17.4 T 5385-1764 5385-1764-1 12.7 NSV 17343 43 7 06 39.10 -09 59 31.5 M 5385-1709 12.7 44 7 06 35.70 -10 07 12.7 T 5385-0800 5385- 800-1 12.7 45 7 07 00.80 -10 04 42.0 M 5385-0144 12.8 46 7 07 04.81 -09 59 31.9 M 5385-0535 12.9 47 7 06 56.73 -09 59 07.0 M 5385-0315 12.9 48* 7 06 57.4 -10 04 25 M 5385-0762 13.0 49 7 07 03.45 -10 03 17.3 M 5385-1993 13.1 50 7 07 17.47 -09 57 23.5 M 5385-1078 13.1 51 7 06 46.58 -10 05 45.2 M 5385-0733 13.2 52 7 06 38.07 -10 07 19.9 M 5385-0981 13.4 53 7 07 06.47 -09 59 14.1 M 5385-0336 13.4 NSV 17345 54 7 06 56.20 -10 07 24.7 M 5385-1374 13.5 55 7 06 54.06 -10 06 06.2 M 5385-0086 13.5 56 7 07 16.92 -09 58 13.2 M 5385-0727 13.7 57 7 06 56.05 -10 04 29.7 M 13.8 58 7 06 51.32 -10 05 07.2 M 5385-0455 13.9 59* 14.0 60 7 06 59.49 -10 06 40.3 M 14.0 61 7 07 03.59 -10 01 08.7 M 5385-0974 13.5 Seggewiss 6 62 7 06 42.15 -10 03 34.4 M 14.0 Seggewiss 7 63 7 06 49.07 -09 59 15.1 M 14.3 Seggewiss 8 Notes 4 MSX5C G223.6255-01.1810. 9 MSX5C G223.6808-01.3236. 14 position for brighter of a pair; Claria photometry for combined light. 24 position for brighter of ~6" pair; Claria photometry for combined light. 48 mean position for pair; Claria photometry for combined light. 59 not labelled on chart.