The 14 stars in NGC 6193 observed by Moffat & Vogt are present in SIMBAD with a mix of approximate and accurate coordinates, but all the photometry is shown. I noticed that there were large numbers of stars in the region having obvious multiple entries in SIMBAD under different names. As a start in cleaning this up, I have determined coordinates and IDs for the principal stars in the survey by Herbst & Havlen (1977A&AS...30..279H), and for stars lacking accurate coordinates in SIMBAD from the early study by Whiteoak (1963MNRAS.125..105W). Part of the mess is in the nomenclature, some of which arises from the extension of the Moffat & Vogt NGC 6193 numbers to include some stars from Whiteoak---at least the Whiteoak photometry is cited for these stars. The numbering scheme proceeds from the last of the Moffat & Vogt stars (i.e. 'NGC 6193 nn', where nn >= 15), e.g. NGC 6193 23 = [W63] 57. The 'Dictionary' shows no numbers higher than 14 that lack an additional specifier. I don't know what's going on here, since there are no citations for these higher-numbered entries, but it's also possible that numbers from Vazquez & Feinstein (1992A&AS...92..863V) have been included somehow. Another problem is that the Whiteoak UBV photometry has been erroneously added to more than one star. Some of these are mentioned in the notes at the bottom of the Whiteoak list below, but there are probably more such cases. There are doubtless other stars with multiple SIMBAD entries aliased under the CSI and GEN acronyms, and also the stars from Vega et al. ('Em* VRMF nnn', 1980AJ.....85.1207V) are not well integrated. So there is quite a bit more work to do to clean up SIMBAD in this patch of sky. I note several OB stars in the Herbst & Havlen list that are not LS stars. Nearly all the Whiteoak stars of the general field are also suitable candidates for the ALS OB-stars catalogue. Many of the DM stars are not recoverable in the GCPD by coordinates. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Coordinates and Identifications for stars in NGC 6193 version: 23 Oct 2002 source: 1973A&AS...10..135M cluster center = HD 150136 (star 1): 16 41 20 -48 45.8 (J2000) position sources (column 's'): G GSC-ACT (1999GSCTy.C......0G, I/255) g GSC-2.2 (2001GSC2..C......0S, I/271) T Tycho-2 (2000A&A...357..367H, I/259) U UCAC1 (2000AJ....120.2131Z, I/268) ID RA (J2000) Dec s GSC Tycho-2 V remarks 1 16 41 20.45 -48 45 46.7 T 8334-1503 8334-1503-1 5.7 HD 150136 2 16 41 19.45 -48 45 47.5 T 8334-1505 8334-1505-1 6.9 HD 150135 3 16 41 28.86 -48 47 47.8 T 8334-1242 8334-1242-1 9.0 CD-48 11074 4 16 41 36.31 -48 47 14.9 U 8334-1282 8334-1282-1 10.3 CD-48 11080 5* 16 41 34.91 -48 46 24.2 U 8334-1079 8334-1079-1 10.5 CD-48 11077 6 16 41 33.21 -48 45 06.6 U 8334-1371 8334-1371-1 10.1 CD-48 11075 7 16 41 25.86 -48 45 14.2 T 8334-1053 8334-1053-1 8.5 CD-48 11071 8* 16 41 22.10 -48 44 57.0 U 8330-5406 9.6 CPD-48 8704 9 16 41 24.40 -48 45 52.5 U 8334-1480 12.3 10 16 41 24.04 -48 46 17.5 U 8334-1259 12.3 11 16 41 18.87 -48 44 31.1 G 8330-5276 12.5 12 16 41 31.67 -48 46 43.5 U 8334-1273 12.6 13 16 41 28.51 -48 46 22.2 g 14.8 14 16 41 17.80 -48 47 05.5 g 14.0 Notes 5 brightest of 11" trio. 8 brightest of 9" trio. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- source: 1977A&AS...30..279H HERBST W. and HAVLEN R.J. Astron. Astrophys., Suppl. Ser., 30, 279-295 (1977) Ara OB1, NGC 6193, and Ara R1: an optical study of a very young southern complex. Dictionary: Table 4: <[HH77] NNN> (Nos 1-702). >> this list shows stars with photoelectric photometry and those with >> spectral types; stars with only photographic photometry are omitted. HH77 RA (J2000) Dec s GSC V B-V MK remarks 1 16 41 19.06 -48 38 15.6 U 12.93 0.73 A 11 16 41 41.99 -48 38 35.1 U 8330-5283 13.19 1.47 21 16 41 38.99 -48 40 04.5 U 13.06 0.63 26 16 41 17.83 -48 40 56.5 U 13.95 0.77 28* 16 41 36.58 -48 40 49.4 U 14.7 0.8 29 16 41 41.92 -48 40 53.9 U 14.54 1.35 30 16 41 47.79 -48 40 32.2 U 8330-5262 12.49 0.42 A 38 16 41 57.32 -48 41 37.1 U 14.43 1.00 39 16 41 51.23 -48 41 25.9 U 13.86 0.70 41 16 41 49.53 -48 41 54.6 U 8330-5117 12.18 0.29 A0 43 16 41 49.38 -48 42 07.0 U 8330-5132 9.91 1.11 G8 CD-48 11085 58 16 41 29.28 -48 42 29.3 U 13.3 0.5 A 65 16 42 02.20 -48 42 48.2 U 8330-5137 11.50 0.74 F CPD-48 8728 66 16 42 05.57 -48 42 39.2 U 8330-5359 13.11: 0.67: 68 16 42 07.51 -48 43 16.3 U 13.53 0.70 G0 75 16 41 35.31 -48 43 21.6 U 8330-5147 11.76 0.30 B8 CD-48 11078 84 16 41 36.98 -48 44 23.1 U 14.0 0.9 G8 91 16 41 43.57 -48 44 51.4 U 15.08 2.21 96 16 42 00.58 -48 45 25.1 U 8334-1330 11.53 0.32 A0 CPD-48 8725 106 16 42 11.39 -48 45 55.6 U 8334-1483 11.09 0.70 F8 CD-48 11094 108 16 42 11.97 -48 46 19.8 U 8334-1077 12.64 0.59 F4/5 110* 16 41 54.87 -48 46 24.7 U 8334-1075 11.58 1.86 124 16 41 34.91 -48 46 24.2 U 8334-1079 10.42 0.31 OB- CD-48 11077 125 16 41 34.70 -48 46 32.0 U 11.98 0.43 130 16 41 55.68 -48 47 07.7 U 8334-1149 12.38 0.41 133* 16 42 08.63 -48 48 28.7 U 8334-1095 13.1 0.8 K0 135 16 42 04.10 -48 47 55.1 U 8334-1348 11.95 0.62 OB em 137 16 41 54.79 -48 47 48.9 U 14.1 0.7 K2 139 16 41 48.97 -48 47 38.8 U 15.28 1.02 144 16 41 32.55 -48 47 54.4 U 8334-1069 11.95 0.46 B9: 147* 16 41 28.86 -48 47 47.8 T 8334-1242 9.05 1.02 G5 CD-48 11074 166 16 41 48.56 -48 50 42.9 U 13.3 0.5 A 171 16 41 29.71 -48 50 11.1 U 8334-1287 11.52 0.56 A0 CD-48 8709 173 16 41 26.85 -48 50 47.2 U 8334-1087 10.73 0.12 B8 CD-48 11072 175 16 41 21.84 -48 50 42.9 U 8334-0943 12.09 0.33 B9 180 16 41 13.17 -48 50 10.0 U 8333-0530 12.25 0.41 A2 181 16 41 11.96 -48 50 08.8 U 8333-0444 12.89 0.52 184 16 41 11.88 -48 51 14.2 U 8333-0186 13.12 0.59 187 16 41 27.28 -48 52 00.8 U 8334-1125 12.08 0.62 A7 191 16 41 37.61 -48 52 16.6 U 8334-1235 12.05 0.52 F0 194 16 41 46.71 -48 51 36.3 U 8334-1252 10.37 1.04 G5 CD-48 11083 226 16 40 40.98 -48 51 12.1 U 8333-0814 12.24 0.89 228 16 40 37.49 -48 51 34.9 U 13.04 0.38 A0 240 16 41 01.93 -48 49 19.0 U 8333-0880 13.18 0.62 245 16 40 51.50 -48 49 24.3 U 8333-1313 11.24 0.27 B7 CD-48 11059 251 16 40 43.11 -48 49 28.9 U 8333-0200 12.12 0.25 272 16 41 11.07 -48 46 55.7 U 8333-1215 12.00 0.51 OB em 274 16 41 05.78 -48 47 05.6 U 8333-1363 12.21 0.58 G 291 16 41 04.40 -48 46 34.0 U 8333-0694 10.86 0.27 B7 CD-48 11063 302 16 40 55.87 -48 45 23.4 g 13.67 2.13 327 16 40 30.12 -48 44 16.4 U 8329-3268 11.53 1.84 342 16 40 58.94 -48 44 45.9 G 8329-3272 13.40 0.84 349 16 41 18.87 -48 44 31.1 G 8330-5276 12.57 0.55 A0 353 16 41 07.71 -48 43 24.4 g 13.77 0.61 417 16 40 50.08 -48 39 24.0 U 8329-3536 10.7 1.1 G5 CD-48 11058 430 16 40 04.36 -48 46 35.1 U 8333-0058 11.72 0.52 A3 CPD-48 8670 432 16 40 12.54 -48 47 09.5 U 8333-0104 10.23 0.46 F2 CD-48 11043 472 16 40 27.46 -48 51 24.9 G 8333-0016 12.87 2.13 477 16 40 30.26 -48 52 21.4 U 8333-0098 10.25 0.24 A3 CD-48 11050 536 16 40 16.06 -48 58 15.8 U 8333-0074 10.8 1.1 G5 CD-48 11044 540 16 40 05.89 -48 59 08.8 U 8333-0240 11.0 1.2 G8 CD-48 11040 543 16 39 57.94 -48 59 48.5 G 8333-0913 12.49 0.50 F2 551 16 39 29.43 -48 58 03.4 U 13.64 0.95 554* 16 39 20.28 -48 57 16.5 U 8333-1063 12.23 0.51 557 16 39 09.72 -48 55 33.8 U 8333-0700 12.42 0.49 F2 566* 16 39 18.02 -48 54 39.6 U 8333-0220 10.22 0.25 B8 HD 331021 568 16 39 12.96 -48 53 31.6 U 13.24 0.78 572 16 39 22.34 -48 53 03.3 U 8333-0995 10.40 1.51 K0 CD-48 11026 580 16 39 34.55 -48 50 56.4 U 12.98 0.56 G: 581 16 39 26.10 -48 51 47.6 U 8333-1365 11.59 0.57 F5/6 CPD-48 8655 590* 16 39 43.47 -48 49 45.0 U 8333-1577 9.48 1.80 M3 CD-48 11036 593 16 39 36.39 -48 47 55.2 U 8333-0232 12.52 0.60 F 601 16 39 46.37 -48 47 16.1 U 8333-0048 11.61 0.79 G0 CPD-48 8665 608 16 40 43.61 -48 48 51.8 U 8333-0420 9.81 0.39 A7 CD-48 11055 611 16 42 10.26 -48 41 08.5 U 8330-5314 11.2 0.4 B7 CD-48 11092 614 16 42 15.09 -48 38 59.6 U 8330-5243 11.7 0.3 B9 617 16 42 08.88 -48 39 28.3 U 8330-5129 11.8 0.4 B9: 618 16 42 10.36 -48 39 03.2 U 8330-5264 11.6 0.6 A7 619 16 42 09.74 -48 37 09.9 U 8330-5140 12.3 0.6 A 620 16 42 01.23 -48 37 52.5 U 8330-5104 11.4 0.4 B9 CPD-48 8727 621 16 41 49.28 -48 37 19.4 U 8330-5214 11.4 0.2 A2 CPD-48 8722 623* 16 40 21.86 -48 43 49.0 G 8329-3510 11.6 0.9 F:e? 625 16 40 39.08 -48 48 44.3 U 8333-1125 12.1 0.2 B8: 637 16 41 09.21 -48 58 30.0 U 8333-0969 11.8 0.5 A7 640 16 41 28.43 -48 59 16.9 U 8334-1009 10.6 0.8 G0 CD-48 11073 647 16 42 10.90 -48 55 55.2 U 8334-1202 9.9 0.7 F8 CD-48 11091 648 16 42 06.47 -48 55 45.7 U 8334-1274 11.6 0.5 B7 655 16 39 41.83 -48 42 44.2 U 8329-3204 12.2 0.2 A5 667 16 41 25.86 -48 45 14.2 T 8334-1053 8.45 0.17 B0V CD-48 11071 669 16 41 22.10 -48 44 57.0 U 8330-5406 9.55 0.20 B2IV CPD-48 8704 671 16 41 21.82 -48 44 50.2 U 12.21 0.30 672 16 41 21.67 -48 45 05.2 U 11.98 0.33 678 16 40 44.58 -48 45 22.2 T 8333-0944 7.06 0.08 B0III HD 150041 679 16 40 53.26 -48 45 35.2 U 8333-0360 11.21 0.22 B7 CD-48 11061 680* 16 40 52.89 -48 48 50.1 U 8333-1056 10.71 0.18 OB em CD-48 11060 682 16 41 33.21 -48 45 06.6 U 8334-1371 10.04 0.26 B2V CD-48 11075 684 16 41 36.31 -48 47 14.9 U 8334-1282 10.32 0.26 OB em CD-48 11080 686 16 41 46.31 -48 47 41.5 U 8334-1393 10.38 0.25 B2IV CD-48 11082 688 16 41 54.83 -48 45 22.8 U 8334-1176 10.38 0.38 B7 CD-48 11086 690 16 42 00.47 -48 42 32.5 U 8330-5377 10.05 0.31 B7 CD-48 11088 692 16 42 05.69 -48 42 56.8 U 8330-5320 10.59 0.41 B8 CD-48 11090 694 16 41 42.33 -48 35 01.4 U 8330-5348 10.10 0.39 B1IV 695* 16 40 00.09 -48 46 58.4 U 8333-0702 11.02 0.38 B3V CD-48 11039 696 16 39 30.68 -48 51 02.5 U 8333-0100 9.17 0.21 HD 149834 698 16 40 33.90 -48 53 16.1 U 8333-0458 10.39 0.33 OB-pec CD-48 11051 700 16 40 20.94 -48 54 56.2 U 8333-0850 10.91 0.39 OB em CD-48 11046 701 16 41 02.49 -48 53 49.7 U 8333-0340 11.40 0.28 B7 CD-48 11062 702* 16 41 08.48 -48 52 21.6 U 8333-0204 11.0 0.3 B7 CD-48 11065 16 41 19.45 -48 45 47.5 T 8334-1505 6.89 0.17 HD 150135 * 16 41 20.45 -48 45 46.7 T 8334-1503 5.62 0.16 HD 150136 16 38 01.03 -48 51 01.8 U 8333-1160 10.79 0.41 B2V HD 331019 * 16 38 35.65 -48 54 53.3 U 8333-1391 11.50 0.66 B1Vp CD-48 11005 16 48 37.64 -48 04 45.6 U 8330-0182 11.21 0.15 B9III CD-47 11063 Notes 28 approximate photoelectric photometry: V=15.1, B-V=1.1. 110 MSX5C G336.7676-01.6515. 133 probably not 134. 147 MSX5C G336.7024-01.6140. 554 MSX5C G336.3505-01.4560. 566 NSV 20722. 590 MSX5C G336.4864-01.4189. 623 MSX5C G336.6307-01.4316. 680 IRAS S16371-4842. 695 IRAS 16362-4841. 702 MSX5C G336.6066-01.6233. HD 150136 NSV 20732 = MSX5C G336.7116-01.5733. CD-48 11005 vdBH 72c. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- source: 1963MNRAS.125..105W WHITEOAK J.B. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 125, 105-125 (1963) An association of O and B stars in Ara. Dictionary: Table I: <[W63] NNN> N=127; Table II: N=78. >> this list shows stars lacking accurate coordinates in SIMBAD >> as of 23 Oct 2002. [W63] RA (J2000) Dec s GSC CD/CPD V remarks 2* 16 30 26.74 -49 22 24.1 U 8333-0122 CD-49 10726 11.4 4* 16 31 27.36 -49 24 43.6 U 8333-1631 CD-49 10743 11.4 35* 16 39 17.53 -49 37 16.1 U 8333-1109 11.8 CSI-49-1635 40 16 40 00.09 -48 46 58.4 U 8333-0702 CD-48 11039 10.9 42* 16 40 20.94 -48 54 56.2 U 8333-0850 CD-48 11046 10.9 43* 16 40 33.90 -48 53 16.1 U 8333-0458 CD-48 11051 10.4 NGC 6193 17 44 16 40 51.50 -48 49 24.3 U 8333-1313 CD-48 11059 10.7 47* 16 40 53.26 -48 45 35.2 U 8333-0360 CD-48 11061 11.2 49* 16 40 54.58 -47 45 35.7 U 8329-0193 CD-47 10941 10.1 50* 16 41 02.49 -48 53 49.7 U 8333-0340 CD-48 11062 11.4 52 16 41 08.48 -48 52 21.6 U 8333-0204 CD-48 11065 11.0 NGC 6193 22 57* 16 41 33.07 -48 33 59.6 U 8330-5341 CD-48 11076 10.1 NGC 6193 23 65 16 41 54.83 -48 45 22.8 U 8334-1176 CD-48 11086 10.4 NGC 6193 25 66 16 42 00.47 -48 42 32.5 U 8330-5377 CD-48 11088 10.0 NGC 6193 26 67 16 42 05.69 -48 42 56.8 U 8330-5320 CD-48 11090 10.6 NGC 6193 27 76 16 43 31.08 -49 20 38.9 U 8334-1298 CD-49 10917 10.0 81 16 43 54.42 -47 51 44.7 U 8330-4658 CD-47 10989 10.5 GEN# +6.40601081 84* 16 44 16.78 -47 54 42.5 U 8330-5193 CD-47 11004 11.3 86 16 44 30.00 -47 40 47.3 U 8330-3651 CD-47 11009 10.9 GEN# +6.40601086 89* 16 44 34.91 -47 48 04.7 U 8330-3644 CPD-47 7867 11.3 GEN# +6.40601089 93 16 44 52.42 -48 08 11.4 U 8330-0216 CD-47 11016 11.1 GEN# +6.40601093 94* 16 44 53.97 -46 33 13.3 U 8326-1697 11.3 96* 16 45 21.16 -49 01 30.9 U 8334-0530 CD-48 11137 10.7 97* 16 45 14.57 -47 31 53.0 U 8330-2577 11.3 101 16 45 47.04 -47 55 57.1 U 8330-4228 CD-47 11027 9.8 104 16 46 31.53 -46 58 57.9 U 8330-0611 CPD-46 8217 10.9 108 16 46 35.70 -47 05 26.8 U 8330-5096 CPD-46 8220 10.3 CSI-47-16429 111 16 46 44.88 -47 26 07.9 U 8330-2065 CD-47 11039 10.6 123* 16 48 53.46 -47 19 56.7 U 8330-2618 CD-47 11066 11.0 Notes 2 CSI-49-16271 = GEN# +6.40601002. 4 UBV data under GSC 08333-00392 applies to this star. 35 GEN# +6.40601035 = EM* VRMF 97. 42 NGC 6193 16 = CSI-48-16367. 47 NGC 6193 20 = CSI-48-16372. 49 CSI-47-16372 (CF type is wrong---is reddened B star). 50 NGC 6193 21 = CSI-48-16373. 57 SIMBAD eq 2000 position for [W63] 57 is for 1950. 84 CSI-47-16406 = GEN# +6.40601084. 89 UBV data under CD-47 11012 applies to this star. 94 northern/brighter star of 12" pair; UBV data under GSC 08326-02639 applies to this star. 96 UBV data under GSC 08334-0019 = CD-48 11136 applies to this star. 97 CSI-47-16416 = GEN# +6.40601097. 123 CSI-47-16453 = GEN# +6.40601123.