The lists below revisit work I did a few years ago at the request of Jean-Claude Mermilliod to get coordinates for stars in the outer region of NGC 6531 = Messier 21 that appear in a study by Forbes (1996AJ....112.1073F). I originally used screen plots of USNO-A1.0 for the work. I have gone through the list again comparing with current catalogues, notably UCAC1, and have made a large number of verifications and several corrections to the original list. In SIMBAD all the Forbes stars are present but without coordinates. The brighter HD/Tycho/etc stars are present with precise coordinates since they are well-studied. WEBDA shows old GSC v1.1 coordinates for only 14 stars. (Compared to UCAC1, the improved GSC-ACT positions have rms scatter of only ~0".1 in this field!) I did not go over the HD/BD/CD/CPD assignments here since they are likely to be correct in the inner region, and in the outer region all those I supplied to Gerard in 1998 have been added to SIMBAD. I provide complete coordinates (I think for the first time) for the 29 stars in the Hoag et al. photoelectric sequence. For the Zug stars I depended on Jean-Claude's transit tables to get Hoag x,y and thence to RA/Dec. A few Zug stars remain that are not in the Hoag lists. Six stars from the long Forbes list are missing since they appear to be unlabelled on his chart (I could not find them either in 1998 or today): 129 249 273 286 321 343 The Lynga/SIMBAD/WEBDA position for the cluster center is simply wrong. A better center is the position of HD 313693, shown below. Because of strongly varying background absorption the center is not well-defined, so this choice is somewhat arbitrary, but is at least within the main body, unlike the nominal one. =============================================================================== Coordinates and identifications for stars in NGC 6531 = Messier 21 version: 9 Jul 2003 (some 2MASS positions substituted) 25 Dec 2001 (original) cluster center = HD 313693: 18 04 11 -22 29.7 (J2000) position sources (column 's'): A USNO-A2.0 (I/252) G GSC-ACT (I/255) g GSC-2.2 (I/271) M 2MASS (II/246) T Tycho-2 (2000A&A...357..367H, I/259) U UCAC1 (2000AJ....120.2131Z, I/268) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- source: 1961PUSNO..17..343H (photoelectric sequence stars) Hoag RA (J2000) Dec s GSC Tycho-2 1 18 04 12.64 -22 30 03.2 T 6842-0246 6842- 246-1 2 18 04 02.93 -22 33 57.4 U 6842-0425 6842- 425-1 3 18 04 11.14 -22 29 42.0 U 6263-0104 6263- 104-1 4 18 04 12.21 -22 27 24.6 U 6263-0063 6263- 63-1 5 18 03 57.25 -22 31 22.8 U 6842-0685 6842- 685-1 6 18 04 20.71 -22 29 22.1 T 6263-1040 6263-1040-1 7 18 04 24.31 -22 26 18.8 U 6263-1982 6263-1982-1 8 18 04 34.58 -22 30 18.7 T 6842-0076 6842- 76-1 9 18 04 13.28 -22 29 25.1 U 6263-3188 10 18 03 53.05 -22 29 07.2 U 6263-0273 11 18 04 15.82 -22 32 01.5 U 6842-0118 12 18 04 05.94 -22 31 57.4 U 6842-0457 13 18 04 10.20 -22 28 18.9 U 6263-1515 14 18 04 01.13 -22 29 14.3 U 6263-0901 15 18 04 17.62 -22 28 46.0 U 6263-0710 16 18 04 05.33 -22 31 04.1 U 6842-0569 17 18 04 18.98 -22 28 39.0 U 6263-0847 18 18 04 11.26 -22 27 44.9 U 6263-0296 19 18 04 18.58 -22 28 10.9 U 6263-0531 20 18 04 30.28 -22 30 58.2 U 6842-0663 21 18 04 24.08 -22 31 19.4 U 6842-0684 22 18 04 11.83 -22 30 21.1 U 6842-0867 23 18 04 12.89 -22 29 45.1 G 6263-0156 24 18 04 00.91 -22 29 36.7 U 6263-0306 25 18 04 15.98 -22 27 21.1 U 6263-0739 26 18 04 18.60 -22 27 41.7 U 6263-1155 27 18 04 04.72 -22 31 28.3 U 6842-0041 28 18 03 58.67 -22 29 28.1 U 29 18 03 58.71 -22 30 05.9 U ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- source: 1937LicOB..18...89Z (via JCM transit tables) Zug RA (J2000) Dec s GSC Tycho-2 remarks 5 18 04 17.42 -22 29 40.0 T 6263-0525 6263- 525-1 pos = brtr of pair 8 18 03 43.24 -22 30 56.3 U 6842-0029 6842- 29-1 10 18 04 06.64 -22 26 15.9 U 6263-0879 6263- 879-1 12 18 04 05.95 -22 27 14.9 U 6263-0243 6263- 243-1 14 18 03 35.40 -22 24 59.2 U 6263-0552 6263- 552-1 Forbes 100 15 18 04 16.99 -22 30 33.3 U 6842-0432 6842- 432-1 17 18 03 43.33 -22 28 19.5 U 6263-0790 6263- 790-1 20 18 03 43.82 -22 34 29.5 U 6842-0907 6842- 907-1 21 18 04 08.84 -22 25 50.6 U 6263-0312 6263- 312-1 26 18 04 11.37 -22 28 42.3 U 6263-0794 27 18 04 21.43 -22 25 29.9 U 6263-0004 6263- 4-1 pos = SWrn of pair 28 18 04 22.51 -22 29 13.4 U 6263-0084 37 18 04 18.90 -22 32 31.7 U 6842-0251 39 18 04 07.43 -22 29 31.8 U 6263-0072 pair with Zug 57 45 18 03 56.29 -22 30 11.9 U 6842-0694 46 18 04 09.39 -22 30 28.4 U 6842-0985 49 18 04 14.13 -22 29 29.5 U 6263-0481 53 18 04 11.26 -22 27 44.9 U 6263-0296 55 18 04 06.38 -22 25 06.0 U 6263-1272 56 18 04 13.23 -22 27 17.3 U 6263-0745 57 18 04 07.74 -22 29 25.1 U pair with Zug 39 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- source: 1996AJ....112.1073F (Tables 2 & 3) Forbes RA (J2000) Dec s GSC Tycho-2 remarks 1 18 04 08.72 -22 29 26.2 U 2 18 04 08.30 -22 29 09.6 g 3 18 04 08.64 -22 29 02.6 U 4 18 04 11.94 -22 28 42.0 g 5 18 04 11.68 -22 28 49.1 g 6 18 04 08.44 -22 27 36.8 g 7 18 04 09.16 -22 27 33.9 U 8 18 04 05.13 -22 26 04.4 U 9 18 04 08.17 -22 26 48.4 U 10 18 04 09.63 -22 26 41.7 U 11 18 04 10.66 -22 25 50.3 U 12 18 04 07.65 -22 25 56.3 U 13 18 04 05.54 -22 25 55.4 A 14 18 04 05.13 -22 26 04.4 U 15 18 04 02.70 -22 26 33.8 U 6263-0090 16 18 04 02.96 -22 27 38.4 U 17 18 04 02.04 -22 28 10.7 U 18 18 03 55.51 -22 28 42.4 U 19 18 03 56.21 -22 28 44.4 U 20 18 03 57.23 -22 29 25.3 U 21 18 04 00.38 -22 29 21.8 g 22 18 04 01.34 -22 30 48.2 U 23 18 03 58.15 -22 31 17.9 g 24 18 04 03.09 -22 31 06.8 A double 25 18 04 02.24 -22 31 31.2 U 26 18 04 03.47 -22 31 32.2 A 27 18 04 09.55 -22 30 16.9 U 28 18 04 08.73 -22 30 35.9 A 29 18 04 10.41 -22 31 56.9 g 30 18 04 07.62 -22 32 10.5 U double 31 18 04 07.29 -22 32 22.8 U 32 18 04 04.49 -22 32 39.7 U 33 18 03 59.38 -22 32 36.9 U 6842-0937 34 18 03 59.12 -22 32 28.8 g 35 18 03 56.86 -22 33 03.6 U 36 18 03 55.18 -22 33 14.2 U 37 18 03 54.50 -22 32 41.8 U 38 18 03 53.24 -22 31 49.2 U 39 18 03 50.97 -22 32 13.7 U 40 18 03 49.55 -22 32 52.5 U 41 18 03 47.82 -22 33 23.1 U 42 18 03 46.98 -22 33 22.9 U 43 18 03 45.16 -22 33 13.0 U 6842-0325 44 18 03 45.39 -22 32 47.6 U 45 18 03 45.56 -22 33 31.0 U 46 18 03 44.91 -22 33 38.7 U 47 18 03 46.00 -22 33 53.4 U 48 18 03 45.75 -22 34 24.6 U 49 18 03 49.14 -22 34 31.7 U 50 18 03 49.14 -22 34 42.4 U 51 18 03 44.40 -22 35 12.8 U 52 18 03 41.00 -22 34 48.1 U 6842-0588 53 18 03 33.57 -22 35 40.5 U 54 18 03 31.41 -22 35 48.6 U 55 18 03 30.37 -22 35 55.2 U 56 18 03 32.25 -22 35 06.5 U 6842-0004 57 18 03 33.47 -22 34 38.3 U 58 18 03 31.48 -22 34 23.6 U 59 18 03 31.18 -22 33 49.7 U 60 18 03 26.94 -22 34 15.0 U 61 18 03 27.67 -22 33 37.7 U 6842-0397 62 18 03 29.20 -22 33 17.1 U 63 18 03 29.77 -22 32 16.0 U 64 18 03 38.10 -22 31 52.9 U 65 18 03 40.02 -22 31 08.0 U 66 18 03 41.98 -22 31 05.4 U 67 18 03 46.23 -22 30 50.5 A 68 18 03 47.16 -22 30 55.8 U 69 18 03 47.80 -22 31 33.3 U 70 18 03 48.56 -22 32 06.5 U 71 18 03 49.71 -22 31 04.7 U 72 18 03 43.63 -22 30 07.5 U 73 18 03 45.51 -22 29 54.9 U 74 18 03 36.61 -22 29 37.2 U 75 18 03 35.37 -22 29 44.8 U 76 18 03 33.95 -22 30 01.3 U 77 18 03 33.27 -22 30 42.3 U 78 18 03 33.44 -22 30 48.6 g 79 18 03 31.97 -22 31 02.7 U 80 18 03 30.84 -22 31 07.3 U 81 18 03 27.62 -22 31 18.8 U 82 18 03 26.66 -22 31 43.0 U 83 18 03 24.32 -22 30 33.6 U 84 18 03 24.86 -22 29 49.7 U 6263-0146 6263- 146-1 85 18 03 26.50 -22 28 56.2 U 86 18 03 28.66 -22 29 49.5 U 6263-0388 87 18 03 31.99 -22 29 09.7 U 6263-0432 88 18 03 30.73 -22 28 08.1 U 89 18 03 28.86 -22 26 39.7 U 6263-1066 6263-1066-1 90 18 03 38.24 -22 27 40.6 U 91 18 03 38.84 -22 27 58.1 U 6263-0247 92 18 03 41.95 -22 29 04.5 U 6263-0201 93 18 03 44.40 -22 28 37.3 U 94 18 03 48.97 -22 27 51.2 U 6263-0249 6263- 249-1 95 18 03 50.66 -22 27 07.3 U 96 18 03 49.11 -22 26 49.7 U 97 18 03 51.00 -22 26 29.8 U 6263-0785 98 18 03 38.63 -22 25 59.8 U 99 18 03 39.55 -22 25 31.2 U 100 18 03 35.40 -22 24 59.2 U 6263-0552 6263- 552-1 101 18 03 36.38 -22 24 42.8 U 102 18 03 41.84 -22 23 17.2 U 6263-1222 multiple 103 18 03 42.34 -22 22 53.8 U 104 18 03 49.47 -22 23 19.1 U 6263-0057 105 18 03 48.15 -22 21 43.8 U 106 18 03 50.15 -22 21 30.0 A 107 18 03 50.99 -22 22 14.9 A 108 18 03 57.18 -22 23 48.0 U 6263-0497 109 18 03 59.93 -22 25 22.9 U 6263-0226 6263- 226-1 close double? 110 18 04 02.28 -22 24 55.9 U 111 18 04 02.35 -22 23 51.7 U 112 18 04 07.24 -22 24 44.9 U 113 18 04 06.73 -22 23 26.5 U 114 18 04 04.62 -22 23 18.3 U 115 18 04 03.99 -22 23 03.2 U 116 18 03 58.22 -22 22 12.9 A 117 18 03 55.38 -22 22 12.1 g northern of pair 118 18 03 57.54 -22 20 58.4 A 119 18 04 01.95 -22 19 31.7 A 120 18 04 06.57 -22 19 44.6 U 6263-1467 6263-1467-1 121 18 04 05.04 -22 20 44.7 A 122 18 04 05.73 -22 21 23.5 A 123 18 04 08.47 -22 22 02.1 A 124 18 04 08.17 -22 21 43.1 A 125 18 04 08.02 -22 21 35.5 U 126 18 04 09.48 -22 21 09.1 A 127 18 04 11.89 -22 21 54.4 U 128 18 04 11.90 -22 22 28.5 U 130 18 04 13.93 -22 22 22.5 U 131 18 04 15.07 -22 22 15.3 U 6263-1579 6263-1579-1 132 18 04 14.24 -22 21 46.3 A 133 18 04 15.50 -22 21 41.3 A 134 18 04 19.68 -22 20 45.2 U 135 18 04 19.25 -22 20 24.1 U 136 18 04 13.75 -22 19 48.2 U 137 18 04 10.19 -22 18 37.4 U 6263-2223 6263-2223-1 138 18 04 13.69 -22 18 47.7 U 139 18 04 20.91 -22 19 26.2 U 140 18 04 25.29 -22 20 05.3 U 141 18 04 25.93 -22 20 38.7 U 142 18 04 26.65 -22 21 09.8 U NErn of 6" pair 143 18 04 29.34 -22 21 41.9 U 6263-0085 144 18 04 29.98 -22 22 37.7 U 6263-0033 145 18 04 34.56 -22 22 36.7 U 6263-0884 6263- 884-1 146 18 04 35.92 -22 21 38.8 U 147 18 04 37.72 -22 21 53.8 U 6263-0917 close double 148 18 04 34.40 -22 23 10.5 U 149 18 04 31.42 -22 23 38.4 U 150 18 04 25.11 -22 22 52.8 U 151 18 04 21.66 -22 23 21.2 U 152 18 04 23.22 -22 24 48.5 U 6263-0223 153 18 04 26.73 -22 25 28.4 U 154 18 04 28.48 -22 25 10.2 U 155 18 04 36.35 -22 25 03.1 U 6263-0053 6263- 53-1 156 18 04 44.63 -22 24 37.1 U 6263-1402 157 18 04 47.35 -22 24 09.5 U 158 18 04 47.40 -22 23 53.1 U 159 18 04 51.09 -22 23 50.9 g 160 18 04 51.65 -22 23 47.4 g 161 18 04 37.78 -22 25 38.6 U 162 18 04 28.55 -22 26 30.1 U 163 18 04 33.44 -22 26 42.1 U 164 18 04 40.09 -22 26 29.4 U 165 18 04 38.15 -22 27 15.4 U 166 18 04 42.29 -22 27 13.9 U 6263-1287 167 18 04 43.51 -22 27 20.3 U 168 18 04 46.95 -22 26 47.4 U 169 18 04 46.13 -22 27 06.7 g 170 18 04 53.35 -22 26 28.1 U 6263-0376 6263- 376-1 171 18 04 55.79 -22 26 52.9 U 6263-0132 172 18 04 59.37 -22 27 08.9 U 173 18 04 58.58 -22 27 50.0 U 174 18 04 55.04 -22 27 33.7 U 6263-3149 175 18 04 53.66 -22 27 17.5 A 176 18 04 52.00 -22 27 47.9 U 177 18 04 51.59 -22 28 42.6 U 178 18 05 01.51 -22 28 53.3 U 6263-3156 179 18 04 55.56 -22 29 50.8 g 180 18 04 55.44 -22 29 57.9 U 6263-3206 181 18 04 57.00 -22 31 19.5 U 182 18 04 53.49 -22 32 02.1 U 6842-1293 6842-1293-1 183 18 04 55.82 -22 34 02.5 U 184 18 04 49.59 -22 33 35.8 U 185 18 04 47.81 -22 33 17.4 U 186 18 04 40.74 -22 31 47.4 U 187 18 04 39.73 -22 31 12.3 U 6842-0473 188 18 04 38.71 -22 30 29.7 U 189 18 04 37.40 -22 30 51.5 U 190 18 04 34.28 -22 30 48.8 U 191 18 04 33.05 -22 29 35.9 U 192 18 04 34.13 -22 28 24.4 U 193 18 04 30.59 -22 29 05.8 U 194 18 04 28.62 -22 29 18.3 U 195 18 04 27.04 -22 28 57.3 U 196 18 04 28.83 -22 28 46.6 U 197 18 04 28.69 -22 28 26.4 U 198 18 04 23.70 -22 27 19.2 U 199 18 04 17.39 -22 26 16.7 U 200 18 04 18.02 -22 28 02.6 g 201 18 04 20.90 -22 28 07.5 U 202 18 04 16.73 -22 29 21.0 U 203 18 04 20.49 -22 29 03.0 U 204 18 04 20.55 -22 29 56.6 U 205 18 04 14.50 -22 30 30.3 U 206 18 04 16.68 -22 30 22.8 U 6842-0058 207 18 04 24.23 -22 29 13.9 U 208 18 04 21.39 -22 30 05.8 U 209 18 04 18.59 -22 30 41.2 U 210 18 04 17.86 -22 30 49.8 U 211 18 04 19.66 -22 31 13.9 U 212 18 04 22.16 -22 31 53.9 U 213 18 04 19.84 -22 32 01.4 U 214 18 04 17.34 -22 32 21.2 M 215 18 04 17.22 -22 32 24.9 M 216 18 04 26.30 -22 32 38.7 U 217 18 04 27.30 -22 32 22.4 U 6842-0185 218 18 04 30.30 -22 31 50.2 U 219 18 04 30.10 -22 32 31.9 U 220 18 04 30.67 -22 32 59.3 U 221 18 04 31.5 -22 33 41 g mean position for pair 222 18 04 34.53 -22 32 52.4 U 223 18 04 35.21 -22 33 26.4 U 224 18 04 38.36 -22 34 21.5 U 225 18 04 42.51 -22 34 58.9 U 226 18 04 48.03 -22 35 43.1 U 227 18 04 49.97 -22 34 41.0 U 228 18 04 52.84 -22 35 07.5 U 229 18 04 54.86 -22 36 03.0 U 230 18 04 52.38 -22 36 07.4 U 231 18 04 51.27 -22 36 21.2 U 232 18 04 47.45 -22 36 47.4 U 6842-1491 6842-1491-1 233 18 04 44.70 -22 36 35.0 U 234 18 04 41.10 -22 37 04.1 U 235 18 04 38.71 -22 38 06.6 U 236 18 04 33.26 -22 38 07.6 U 237 18 04 32.83 -22 37 39.9 U 6842-0252 238 18 04 35.19 -22 37 34.7 U 239 18 04 35.41 -22 36 22.7 U 240 18 04 32.44 -22 36 14.5 U 241 18 04 30.74 -22 36 33.8 U 242 18 04 29.35 -22 36 32.1 A 243 18 04 27.36 -22 36 47.8 U 6842-0947 6842- 947-1 244 18 04 29.09 -22 35 55.6 U 245 18 04 29.27 -22 35 11.1 U 246 18 04 29.12 -22 34 40.5 U 247 18 04 24.59 -22 33 35.4 U 248 18 04 23.80 -22 33 00.7 U 250 18 04 14.71 -22 31 49.2 U 251 18 04 12.50 -22 31 23.7 A 252 18 04 23.14 -22 34 11.2 U 253 18 04 19.91 -22 34 15.6 U 254 18 04 18.91 -22 34 22.7 U 255 18 04 17.75 -22 34 27.1 U 6842-0244 256 18 04 14.15 -22 33 39.8 U 257 18 04 09.55 -22 33 43.4 U 258 18 04 11.22 -22 34 02.6 U 259 18 04 08.12 -22 34 12.7 U 6842-0245 260 18 04 10.25 -22 34 44.4 U 261 18 04 14.49 -22 34 45.1 U 262 18 04 15.60 -22 34 59.2 U 263 18 04 15.93 -22 35 37.5 U 264 18 04 15.94 -22 35 48.6 A 265 18 04 21.53 -22 36 07.7 U 266 18 04 19.53 -22 36 37.1 U 267 18 04 13.11 -22 36 55.2 A 268 18 04 14.70 -22 37 51.0 U 269 18 04 11.91 -22 38 18.3 U 6842-0636 6842- 636-1 270 18 04 12.30 -22 38 42.2 g 271 18 04 11.91 -22 38 37.7 A 272 18 04 12.70 -22 38 58.1 U 274 18 04 19.06 -22 38 32.4 U 6842-0452 275 18 04 25.07 -22 38 37.6 U 276 18 04 27.21 -22 39 14.8 U 6842-0798 277 18 04 27.10 -22 39 38.0 U 278 18 04 27.08 -22 40 20.3 U 279 18 04 25.53 -22 39 39.1 U 280 18 04 23.12 -22 39 55.9 U 281 18 04 26.33 -22 41 21.7 U 282 18 04 23.81 -22 41 07.9 U 283 18 04 23.51 -22 41 15.6 M NWrn of close pair 284 18 04 19.61 -22 41 02.6 U 285 18 04 16.77 -22 40 46.0 g 287 18 04 13.03 -22 41 18.0 T 6842-0572 6842- 572-1 288 18 04 07.67 -22 41 33.4 U 6842-0897 289 18 04 08.32 -22 41 23.9 U 290 18 04 10.41 -22 39 52.5 U 291 18 04 10.66 -22 40 23.6 U 292 18 04 11.62 -22 40 35.1 U 293 18 04 15.77 -22 40 19.0 U 6842-0059 294 18 04 16.83 -22 39 39.0 U 295 18 04 16.17 -22 39 25.0 U 296 18 04 15.72 -22 39 33.3 U 297 18 04 18.69 -22 38 56.5 U 6842-0190 6842- 190-1 298 18 04 06.84 -22 38 12.2 U 299 18 04 05.58 -22 38 32.0 A 300 18 04 00.74 -22 38 33.5 U 301 18 03 51.42 -22 39 22.5 g 302 18 03 51.07 -22 39 24.7 g 303 18 03 51.32 -22 39 37.5 U 304 18 03 51.44 -22 40 35.5 U 305 18 03 49.58 -22 39 54.5 U 306 18 03 47.02 -22 39 33.7 U 307 18 03 43.81 -22 38 30.9 U 308 18 03 42.72 -22 38 45.0 U 309 18 03 36.25 -22 37 57.5 U 310 18 03 35.14 -22 37 27.6 U 311 18 03 34.81 -22 37 07.7 U 312 18 03 37.24 -22 37 34.0 U 313 18 03 43.02 -22 37 17.3 U 314 18 03 44.01 -22 37 10.3 U 315 18 03 44.12 -22 37 27.3 U 316 18 03 47.03 -22 37 40.3 U 317 18 03 49.05 -22 37 30.8 U 318 18 03 51.98 -22 37 31.2 U 319 18 03 53.26 -22 37 21.8 U 320 18 03 58.88 -22 37 05.7 U 322 18 04 03.10 -22 38 05.7 U 323 18 04 06.19 -22 37 46.3 U 324 18 04 04.11 -22 37 28.1 U 6842-0409 325 18 04 09.13 -22 36 33.8 U 326 18 04 10.62 -22 36 21.6 U 327 18 04 12.83 -22 36 21.1 U 328 18 04 11.82 -22 36 02.8 U 329 18 04 05.46 -22 35 02.8 U 330 18 04 05.60 -22 34 01.5 g 331 18 04 04.93 -22 33 07.4 U 332 18 04 04.08 -22 33 13.7 U 333 18 03 58.24 -22 34 30.1 U 334 18 03 59.75 -22 35 01.8 U 6842-0136 335 18 03 57.73 -22 35 14.4 U 336 18 03 59.10 -22 36 10.7 U 6842-0141 337 18 04 03.62 -22 36 42.2 U 338 18 03 57.45 -22 36 06.7 U 339 18 03 55.94 -22 36 23.8 U 340 18 03 55.85 -22 35 50.0 U 341 18 03 52.63 -22 35 28.4 U 342 18 03 50.46 -22 35 29.9 U 344 18 04 24.65 -22 34 31.8 U